header-logo header-logo

Home Login E-newsletter About us
11 September 2026 / Laura Davidson
Issue: 8176 / Categories: Features , Court of Protection , Mental health , Human rights
printer mail-detail

A gilded cage is no longer a cage

© Copyright LexisNexis 2026. All Rights Reserved.
258567
© Getty images
With Cheshire West overturned, Laura Davidson considers whether a more flexible approach to deprivation of liberty comes at the cost of vital safeguards
  • The Supreme Court has overturned Cheshire West’s ‘acid test’, replacing it with a broader, contextual assessment of deprivation of liberty that gives greater weight to consent, wishes and feelings, and the purpose and effect of restrictions.
  • Questions remain over whether this more flexible approach risks weakening safeguards for vulnerable adults, particularly those whose disability or dependency makes it difficult to express objection or distinguish genuine consent from passive acquiescence.

Twelve years after its judgment in Cheshire West and Chester Council v P [2014] UKSC 19, the Supreme Court has overturned its own decision. The Attorney General for Northern Ireland brought a reference (Re Attorney General for Northern Ireland’s Reference [2026] UKSC 16), wishing to revise the Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards Code of Practice under Northern Ireland’s Mental Capacity Act 2016. The draft code indicated that not everyone lacking mental

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Read All
Sponsored by
Speechlive LogoClick to know more
Fieldfisher—Julian Balson

Fieldfisher—Julian Balson

Indirect tax investigations and litigation specialist strengthens contentious tax offering

DMH Stallard—Seb Jones

DMH Stallard—Seb Jones

DMH Stallard makes Magic Circle hire

TV Edwards—Sarah Inchley, Caroline Andrews & Cheryl Thompson

TV Edwards—Sarah Inchley, Caroline Andrews & Cheryl Thompson

Three new Heads announced at leading London-based law firm

NEWS
Read All
NLJ this week: A wider test for unsafe homes
A High Court decision has clarified that a home may be unfit for human habitation not only where conditions endanger health or safety, but also where they seriously undermine comfort and convenience
NLJ this week: Employment deadlines lengthen

A longer time limit for employment tribunal claims, new charity law thresholds, property tribunal recruitment and appellate guidance on small-claims costs feature in the latest Civil Way round-up

NLJ this week: Estoppel crosses borders
A recent High Court ruling could make issue estoppel considerably more complex in cross-border litigation, requiring parties to consider the foreign law governing the underlying claim
NLJ this week: Safeguards under strain
The Supreme Court has overturned Cheshire West’s bright-line test for deprivation of liberty, replacing it with a broader, more contextual assessment that gives greater weight to an individual’s wishes, feelings and apparent consent
NLJ this week: Fraud reform’s delivery test
Jonathan Fisher KC’s wide-ranging fraud report contains worthwhile proposals, but turning them into workable reform will require money, capacity and political will
Copyright © 2026 LexisNexis
back-to-top-scroll