header-logo header-logo

06 August 2009 / Finola Moss
Issue: 7381 / Categories: Features , Family
printer mail-detail

Dangerous consensus?

What happens when expert evidence is unreliable? Finola Moss reports

Such is the Law Commission’s concern about the reliability of expert evidence in criminal proceedings it has proposed that an expert’s trustworthiness be formally proved.

Professor Jeremy Hodder, leading the consultation, warns: “Expert evidence, particularly scientific evidence, can have a very persuasive effect on juries. It is vital that such evidence should only be used if it provides a sound basis for determining a defendant’s guilt or innocence.”

The effect of such evidence on courts deciding the welfare of children and their permanent removal from their families is not considered.
In 2004 Margaret Hodge, the then children’s minister, instructed councils to review all final care orders that depended “exclusively, or almost exclusively, on a serious disagreement between medical experts about the cause of harm”.

It is difficult to envisage how any expert evidence could satisfy this definition, within the quasi-inquisitorial regime of care proceedings, where consensus is coerced by the need for joint instruction and agreement of expert evidence.

The child’s guardian normally endorses the

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Clyde & Co—Nav Juty

Clyde & Co—Nav Juty

ArcelorMittal global head of disputes Nav Juty appointed as partner

Shakespeare Martineau—Caroline Hastings

Shakespeare Martineau—Caroline Hastings

Shakespeare Martineau strengthens Birmingham agricultural team

Fieldfisher—Peter McKeever

Fieldfisher—Peter McKeever

Fieldfisher Ireland appoints Peter McKeever as real estate partner

NEWS
The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) has hiked the practising fee for individuals from £190 to £240, as the regulator implements a ‘reset’
Businesses incorporating open-source software into commercial products could face obligations to disclose valuable source code, with AI-assisted development making licensing risks harder to track
Careless client checks do not automatically make a solicitor dishonest, but deliberately avoiding confirmation of suspected wrongdoing can cross the line
Construction workers injured in comparable accidents can face sharply different routes to compensation on opposite sides of the Atlantic
Victims of undue influence may have more options than simply unwinding a tainted transaction, with courts able to order profits accounts, compensation and, exceptionally, severance
back-to-top-scroll