Rebecca Smart on how to get the balance right in criminal trials
Debate about criminal justice too often presents a false choice—protect complainants or safeguard defendants’ rights. A fair trial must do both. It must enable witnesses to give their best evidence while preserving the accused’s right to test the case through robust, relevant and appropriate questioning. Dignity and due process are not competing ambitions; each helps make the other meaningful.
Before calling for new protections, it is worth examining the extensive framework that already exists. Much of the public debate proceeds as though complainants enter the criminal justice system unsupported. The reality is considerably more nuanced.
Protection that enables evidence
Much of the recent commentary surrounding high-profile criminal trials has overlooked the substantial protections already available to complainants in England and Wales. Giving evidence in a criminal case remains a daunting and often deeply personal experience. No procedural safeguard can entirely remove the stress of having one’s account scrutinised in court, nor eliminate the emotional impact of giving evidence about




