header-logo header-logo

24 September 2018 / Dr Ping-fat Sze
Issue: 7811 / Categories: Features , Criminal
printer mail-detail

International justice: a matter of grave concern

As part of an occasional series on international justice & the Rule of Law in other jurisdictions, Dr Ping-fat Sze investigates the misuse of prosecutorial discretion in Hong Kong

  • The Rule of Law and the administration of justice in Hong Kong.
  • HKSAR v Khan and plea bargaining.
  • The role of the Department of Justice in criminal prosecutions and the potential for miscarriages of justice.

The Rule of Law and generally, the administration of justice in Hong Kong, have been repeatedly downgraded by international agencies (including the Human Rights Monitor and the World Economic Forum) in recent years especially after the imprisonment of a number of the student leaders involved in the Umbrella Movement which took place in autumn 2014.

The misuse of prosecutorial discretion in this former British colony was first noted in an article published in 2009 (173 JPN 53; see also 181 JPN 111 & 310). For a number of reasons, the judiciary has been reluctant to intervene in the exercise of this discretion by the Department

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Switalskis—Sally Ann Masih, Suzy Overton & Jane Beaumont

Switalskis—Sally Ann Masih, Suzy Overton & Jane Beaumont

Trio of recruits strengthens Switalskis residential property team

Ward Hadaway—Steven Hayward

Ward Hadaway—Steven Hayward

Birmingham law firm appoints construction partner

Flint Bishop—six appointments

Flint Bishop—six appointments

Flint Bishop accelerates Northern growth through strategic senior appointments

NEWS
A High Court decision has clarified that a home may be unfit for human habitation not only where conditions endanger health or safety, but also where they seriously undermine comfort and convenience

A longer time limit for employment tribunal claims, new charity law thresholds, property tribunal recruitment and appellate guidance on small-claims costs feature in the latest Civil Way round-up

A recent High Court ruling could make issue estoppel considerably more complex in cross-border litigation, requiring parties to consider the foreign law governing the underlying claim
The Supreme Court has overturned Cheshire West’s bright-line test for deprivation of liberty, replacing it with a broader, more contextual assessment that gives greater weight to an individual’s wishes, feelings and apparent consent
Jonathan Fisher KC’s wide-ranging fraud report contains worthwhile proposals, but turning them into workable reform will require money, capacity and political will
back-to-top-scroll