Professor Graham Zellick KC traces the dispute over the CCRC’s independence & argues that Parliament must give clearer guidance on when past convictions should be revisited
- The Court of Appeal’s approach to convictions affected by changes in case law curtailed the CCRC’s independence; subsequent legislation left the test for revisiting such convictions unclear.
- The author calls for Parliament to set clearer rules that balance finality with the need to correct substantive miscarriages of justice.
Part 1 of this article addressed the issue of how a change in the common law affects a past conviction, and a Divisional Court judgment that upheld the Criminal Cases Review Commission’s independence. Part 2 now picks up the story as the Court of Appeal in an unrelated case (R v Cottrell; R v Fletcher [2007] EWCA Crim 2016) expresses its unhappiness with the Divisional Court, and sets out how Parliament intervened to resolve the conflict.
The courts collide
Sir Igor




