header-logo header-logo

03 October 2019
Issue: 7858 / Categories: Features , Procedure & practice , Civil way
printer mail-detail

Civil way: 4 October 2019

Vindication rules, OK!; silence: out of court; silence: in form E; service charge costs escape

PART 36: GOOD FOR REPUTATION

Where the claimant’s sole motive for their CPR Pt 36 offer was to be vindicated, that could still earn them their costs. In Ashley v Chief Constable of Sussex [2008] UKHL 25, [2008] All ER (D) 326 (Apr), it had been held that a public acknowledgment that the claimant had suffered a wrong might play as an important role as an award of damages. And now along comes MR v Commissioner of Police for the Metropolis [2019] EWHC 1970 (QB), [2019] All ER (D) 42 (Sep) in which McGowan J declared that, as a matter of principle, the implications of costs should never overwhelm the issue at the centre of litigation. Worth writing out on the insides of your eyelids for advocacy of the future.

MR had alleged false imprisonment and assault, allied to a police arrest. The final Pt 36 of a series contributed to by both sides came from the claimant

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

HFW—Nelson Wang

HFW—Nelson Wang

HFW strengthens global insurance practice and Greater China offering with London Partner hire

Burges Salmon—David McEwing

Burges Salmon—David McEwing

Burges Salmon boosts Energy and Utilities practice with appointment of David McEwing

Browne Jacobson—Alexander Studholme

Browne Jacobson—Alexander Studholme

Browne Jacobson adds international construction arbitration partner in London push

NEWS
A former senior judge has warned peers against scrapping juries for fraud and financial crimes, ahead of the Courts and Tribunals Bill’s second reading in the House of Lords this week
Civil practitioners face changes spanning debt recovery, workplace harassment and possession claims, alongside guidance on insolvency challenges and children proceedings

Finding matrimonial wealth is as challenging as dividing it, as family disputes draw practitioners into asset tracing, offshore structures and insolvency

Agreement between opponents offers no guarantee that a court will approve a retrospective increase to a costs budget
Climate change belongs on every lawyer’s agenda, with risks extending far beyond environmental practice into commercial advice, litigation and access to justice
back-to-top-scroll