header-logo header-logo

Corroboration matters in expert assessments

20 September 2024 / Dr Tanya Garrett
Issue: 8086 / Categories: Features , Profession , Expert Witness , National Health Service , Health
printer mail-detail
189718
Medical & other information is vital for experts carrying out assessments. Dr Tanya Garrett explains why—& why obtaining it isn’t always easy
  • Medical records and other corroborative information are essential for substantive psychological and some other expert assessments. This is to control for bias and to avoid over-reliance on the client’s account of the client.
  • This article gives guidance on how to access this material, and how to treat it.

Medical records are vital for experts such as psychologists and psychiatrists in all legal proceedings. A good psychological report will include so-called corroborative information. This is information from independent sources that complements the client’s account, filling in any gaps in their memory, whether trauma-induced or age-related. The client may have been too young to remember certain events from their past or may have ‘forgotten’ them due to trauma.

This really does happen—research shows that people who have experienced significant trauma often cope with adverse experiences by ‘forgetting’ some of them. This information will also help the expert

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Clarke Willmott—Declan Goodwin & Elinor Owen

Clarke Willmott—Declan Goodwin & Elinor Owen

Corporate and commercial teams in Cardiff boosted by dual partner hire

Hill Dickinson—Joz Coetzer & Marc Naidoo

Hill Dickinson—Joz Coetzer & Marc Naidoo

London hires to lead UK launch of international finance team

Switalskis—11 promotions

Switalskis—11 promotions

Firm marks start of year with firmwide promotions round

NEWS
Property lawyers have given a cautious welcome to the government’s landmark Bill capping ground rents at £250, banning new leasehold properties and making it easier for leaseholders to switch to commonhold
Four Nightingale courts are to be made permanent, as justice ministers continue to grapple with the record-level Crown Court backlog
The judiciary has set itself a trio of objectives and a trio of focus areas for the next five years, in its Judicial Diversity and Inclusion Strategy 2026-2030

The Sentencing Act 2026 received royal assent last week, bringing into law the recommendations of David Gauke’s May 2025 Independent Sentencing Review

Victims of crime are to be given free access to transcripts of Crown Court sentencing remarks, the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) has confirmed
back-to-top-scroll