header-logo header-logo

10 July 2014
Issue: 7614 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-detail

Court of Appeal clarifies Mitchell

Ruling in three conjoined appeals places the courts “back on track”

The courts are “back on track” following new guidance on Mitchell from the Court of Appeal in Denton v TH White Ltd; Decadent Vapours Ltd v Bevan; Utilise TDS Ltd v Davies [2014] EWCA Civ 906 (see p 17).

Ruling in three conjoined appeals where one party had sought relief from sanctions under CPR 3.9, Lord Dyson and Lord Justice Vos set out a three-stage test for relief applications.

The court concluded that Mitchell v News Group Newspapers [2013] EWCA Civ 1537 had been “misunderstood” and “misapplied” by the courts in subsequent cases, although it remained a sound decision.

NLJ columnist Professor Dominic Regan, who assisted Lord Justice Jackson in his civil litigation review, says: “While each of the three judges expressly affirmed Mitchell, it is clear that they recognised it was horrifically counter-productive.

“The abandonment of ‘trivia’ and the new three-step test is to be welcomed. The court said orders should not be issued with abandon. Almighty costs sanctions are threatened against those taking bad points and failing to co-operate. We are back on track.”

In Mitchell, strict sanctions were applied for a missed deadline, leaving Andrew Mitchell MP’s legal team unable to recover more than their court fees in costs. The view that the courts would be strict on case management and impose severe penalties created an incentive for litigators to challenge minor breaches or delays by the opposing party. The case led to uncertainty over application and an increase in satellite litigation.

Under the new three-stage test, judges should: identify that the failure to comply is “serious” or “significant” (previous conduct may be a relevant consideration); consider whether there is a good reason it occurred; consider all the circumstances of the case.

Delivering his judgment, Jackson LJ said “co-operation should be encouraged and satellite litigation should be discouraged”.

He added: “The new rule 3.9…is not intended to introduce a harsh regime of almost zero tolerance, as some commentators have suggested.”

Peter Kaye, partner at Linder Myers Solicitors, who acted for Utilise, says the new guidance provided “fair, and clear, definitions with regards to the weight of breaches clarifying those which will warrant the court’s time and should serve to minimise satellite litigation over trivial matters going forward”.

Issue: 7614 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-details

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Clyde & Co—Nav Juty

Clyde & Co—Nav Juty

ArcelorMittal global head of disputes Nav Juty appointed as partner

Shakespeare Martineau—Caroline Hastings

Shakespeare Martineau—Caroline Hastings

Shakespeare Martineau strengthens Birmingham agricultural team

Fieldfisher—Peter McKeever

Fieldfisher—Peter McKeever

Fieldfisher Ireland appoints Peter McKeever as real estate partner

NEWS
The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) has hiked the practising fee for individuals from £190 to £240, as the regulator implements a ‘reset’
Construction workers injured in comparable accidents can face sharply different routes to compensation on opposite sides of the Atlantic
Victims of undue influence may have more options than simply unwinding a tainted transaction, with courts able to order profits accounts, compensation and, exceptionally, severance
Disabled people could lose vital safeguards following the Supreme Court’s reversal of the Cheshire West test for deprivation of liberty, two barristers warn
A formidable reputation cannot protect a law firm when partner departures, fragile finances and client uncertainty begin feeding each other
back-to-top-scroll