header-logo header-logo

Derivative claim against Shell goes up in smoke

20 October 2023 / John Doherty , Richard Raban-Williams
Issue: 8045 / Categories: Features , Environment
printer mail-detail
143309
Richard Raban-Williams & John Doherty review an innovative attempt to challenge Shell’s climate change policies
  • The first recorded attempt to use a derivative action to hold directors liable for a company’s climate crisis response has been brought by ClientEarth.
  • Explains why the claim failed in the High Court. However, it may be appealed.
  • The requirement for good faith and the views of other shareholders may be of consequence to future derivative actions.

Like the wildfires that have raged across the globe recently, disputes related to climate change continue to flare up. Most recently, in July 2023, the High Court in London handed down its final judgment in a claim brought by ClientEarth against Shell and its board of directors.

The decision is the first recorded attempt to use a derivative action to hold directors liable for a company’s response to the climate crisis. ClientEarth sought injunctive and declaratory relief, rather than damages, presumably reflecting the challenges presented by demonstrating shareholder loss in the context of

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

FOIL—Bridget Tatham

FOIL—Bridget Tatham

Forum of Insurance Lawyers elects president for 2026

Gibson Dunn—Robbie Sinclair

Gibson Dunn—Robbie Sinclair

Partner joinslabour and employment practice in London

Muckle LLP—Ella Johnson

Muckle LLP—Ella Johnson

Real estate dispute resolution team welcomes newly qualified solicitor

NEWS
Cryptocurrency is reshaping financial remedy cases, warns Robert Webster of Maguire Family Law in NLJ this week. Digital assets—concealable, volatile and hard to trace—are fuelling suspicions of hidden wealth, yet Form E still lacks a section for crypto-disclosure
NLJ columnist Stephen Gold surveys a flurry of procedural reforms in his latest 'Civil way' column
Paper cyber-incident plans are useless once ransomware strikes, argues Jack Morris of Epiq in NLJ this week
In this week's NLJ, Robert Hargreaves and Lily Johnston of York St John University examine the Employment Rights Bill 2024–25, which abolishes the two-year qualifying period for unfair-dismissal claims
Writing in NLJ this week, Manvir Kaur Grewal of Corker Binning analyses the collapse of R v Óg Ó hAnnaidh, where a terrorism charge failed because prosecutors lacked statutory consent. The case, she argues, highlights how procedural safeguards—time limits, consent requirements and institutional checks—define lawful state power
back-to-top-scroll