header-logo header-logo

21 November 2012
Issue: 7539 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-detail

Employer wins fake tickets case

Court of Appeal uphold sacking of train conductor

A train conductor sacked for selling fake tickets to passengers for personal profit could not rely on human rights law to support her unfair dismissal claim.

Ruling in Turner v East Midlands Trains [2012] EWCA Civ 1470, the Court of Appeal held that East Midlands Trains employee Heather Turner could not rely on Art 8 (respect for private life) where the damage to reputation was the foreseeable consequence of her own actions.

It held that the “band of reasonable responses” test for determining fairness was consistent with the proportionality test contained in Art 8(2) of the European Convention on Human Rights.

Turner was dismissed when her employer discovered she was selling tickets from a portable machine which classed them as “non-issues”, and keeping the proceeds. She brought a claim of unfair dismissal, arguing that Art 8 applied because her dismissal interfered with her relationships with colleagues and damaged her reputation and future job prospects. She argued the employment tribunal must apply a proportionality test rather than the “band of reasonable responses” test.

Dismissing the appeal, Lord Justice Elias said: “I am satisfied that, so far as procedures are concerned, the domestic test of fairness does not fall short of the procedural safeguards required by Art 8.

“In that context, I reject the appellant’s submission that the concept of proportionality is either a helpful or relevant one when considering the fairness of the procedures.”

Allan Finlay, partner at Kennedys, which represented East Midlands Trains, says: “This judgment is a welcome affirmation of the band of reasonable responses test for employers...Had the appeal been successful, defending unfair dismissal claims would have become much more of a lottery.”

Issue: 7539 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-details

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Clyde & Co—Nav Juty

Clyde & Co—Nav Juty

ArcelorMittal global head of disputes Nav Juty appointed as partner

Shakespeare Martineau—Caroline Hastings

Shakespeare Martineau—Caroline Hastings

Shakespeare Martineau strengthens Birmingham agricultural team

Fieldfisher—Peter McKeever

Fieldfisher—Peter McKeever

Fieldfisher Ireland appoints Peter McKeever as real estate partner

NEWS
The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) has hiked the practising fee for individuals from £190 to £240, as the regulator implements a ‘reset’
Construction workers injured in comparable accidents can face sharply different routes to compensation on opposite sides of the Atlantic
Victims of undue influence may have more options than simply unwinding a tainted transaction, with courts able to order profits accounts, compensation and, exceptionally, severance
Disabled people could lose vital safeguards following the Supreme Court’s reversal of the Cheshire West test for deprivation of liberty, two barristers warn
A formidable reputation cannot protect a law firm when partner departures, fragile finances and client uncertainty begin feeding each other
back-to-top-scroll