header-logo header-logo

16 October 2014
Issue: 7626 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-detail

Escaping the shadow of Mitchell

High Court overturns overly harsh relief from sanctions ruling

A relief from sanctions ruling which relied heavily on Mitchell principles was overly harsh, the High Court has held.

Ruling in Long v Value Properties [2014] EWHC 2981 (Ch), Mr Justice Barling overturned Master Rowley’s “reluctant” refusal to grant relief after a conditional fee agreement and other documents were submitted after an agreed date. He noted that the defendants had tried to take advantage of the failure to submit on time.

The defendants had argued that the £48,462 success fees of counsel and solicitor were not recoverable because of the non-compliance. The claimants countered that a telephone call, e-mail or fax would have resolved the omission, that no prejudice had been caused, and that they would apply for relief from sanction. Master Rowley had indicated that he had no choice, when he heard the case in January, because he had to apply the principles set out in Mitchell v News Group Newspapers Ltd [2013] EWCA Civ 1537.

However, the case pre-dates the Court of Appeal’s decision in Denton v WH White Ltd & Others [2014] EWCA Civ 906, which clarified the principles on sanctions made in Mitchell, and provided guidance on the interpretation of CPR r.3.9 relating to relief from sanctions for breach of rules, practice directions and orders. According to Denton, the judge should take all the circumstances of the case into consideration and relief should be granted unless the breach is serious or significant.

Granting relief, Barling J said: “The defendants’ behaviour here has been precisely the kind of opportunistic, and non-cooperative conduct in litigation condemned by the Court of Appeal in Denton. Had the defendants taken a different course the matter could probably have been completely resolved within the overall period of the extension of time which they applied for and were granted by the claimant, or very soon thereafter.”

NLJ columnist Professor Dominic Regan, of City Law School, says: “So many judges were thrown by the Mitchell decision.

“This was an example of someone knowing that their order was wrong yet still making it (hence the reluctance comment). The outcome was an utter travesty. Denton has done so much good.”

Issue: 7626 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-details

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Clyde & Co—Nav Juty

Clyde & Co—Nav Juty

ArcelorMittal global head of disputes Nav Juty appointed as partner

Shakespeare Martineau—Caroline Hastings

Shakespeare Martineau—Caroline Hastings

Shakespeare Martineau strengthens Birmingham agricultural team

Fieldfisher—Peter McKeever

Fieldfisher—Peter McKeever

Fieldfisher Ireland appoints Peter McKeever as real estate partner

NEWS
The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) has hiked the practising fee for individuals from £190 to £240, as the regulator implements a ‘reset’
Businesses incorporating open-source software into commercial products could face obligations to disclose valuable source code, with AI-assisted development making licensing risks harder to track
Careless client checks do not automatically make a solicitor dishonest, but deliberately avoiding confirmation of suspected wrongdoing can cross the line
Construction workers injured in comparable accidents can face sharply different routes to compensation on opposite sides of the Atlantic
Victims of undue influence may have more options than simply unwinding a tainted transaction, with courts able to order profits accounts, compensation and, exceptionally, severance
back-to-top-scroll