header-logo header-logo

Expats lose human rights appeal in pensions case

27 March 2010
Issue: 7410 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-detail

British expats are not entitled to have their pensions index-linked, the European Court of Human Rights has ruled

In Carson and Ors v UK (App No 42184/05), 13 claimants argued their state pensions should be up-rated to bring them in line with pensioners living in the UK.

They claimed the difference in treatment amounted to discrimination and breached Art 14 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
Some 500,000 pensioners living abroad would benefit from up-rating.

However, the court found they were not in the same position as pensioners retiring in the UK or in a country with which the UK has a reciprocal agreement.

There were too many economic and social variables to allow for a comparison between pensioners in the UK and abroad.

The court did not consider the applicants’ payment of National Insurance contributions “to be of any more significance than the fact that they may have paid income tax or other taxes while domiciled there”.

Carson, who lives in South Africa, receives £67.50 a week compared with the £95.25 given to UK pensioners.
 

Issue: 7410 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-details

MOVERS & SHAKERS

CBI South-East Council—Mike Wilson

CBI South-East Council—Mike Wilson

Blake Morgan managing partner appointed chair of CBI South-East Council

Birketts—Phillippa O’Neill

Birketts—Phillippa O’Neill

Commercial dispute resolution team welcomes partner in Cambridge

Charles Russell Speechlys—Matthew Griffin

Charles Russell Speechlys—Matthew Griffin

Firm strengthens international funds capability with senior hire

NEWS
The proposed £11bn redress scheme following the Supreme Court’s motor finance rulings is analysed in this week’s NLJ by Fred Philpott of Gough Square Chambers
In this week's issue, Stephen Gold, NLJ columnist and former district judge, surveys another eclectic fortnight in procedure. With humour and humanity, he reminds readers that beneath the procedural dust, the law still changes lives
Generative AI isn’t the villain of the courtroom—it’s the misunderstanding of it that’s dangerous, argues Dr Alan Ma of Birmingham City University and the Birmingham Law Society in this week's NLJ
James Naylor of Naylor Solicitors dissects the government’s plan to outlaw upward-only rent review (UORR) clauses in new commercial leases under Schedule 31 of the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill, in this week's NLJ. The reform, he explains, marks a seismic shift in landlord-tenant power dynamics: rents will no longer rise inexorably, and tenants gain statutory caps and procedural rights
Writing in NLJ this week, James Harrison and Jenna Coad of Penningtons Manches Cooper chart the Privy Council’s demolition of the long-standing ‘shareholder rule’ in Jardine Strategic v Oasis Investments
back-to-top-scroll