header-logo header-logo

Force Majeure?

14 January 2010 / Mark Bowman
Issue: 7400 / Categories: Features , Personal injury
printer mail-detail

Mark Bowman suggests when to see beyond an Act of God

The 18 January 2007 was one of the windiest days in Britain for years. Planes, trains and ferry services were cancelled, motorways closed and hundreds of trees fell as winds of in excess of 90 miles per hour were reported.

Mr M, a lecturer at Southgate College in London, had completed his classes for the morning and was walking along the main driveway of part of the college campus when a sudden gust of wind blew over a mature copper beech tree, adjacent to a car park (where hundreds of students/lecturers would pass each day). The tree landed on Mr M and he suffered severe spinal and psychiatric injuries as a result. He was subsequently medically retired on the grounds of ill health.

Act of God?

At first glance it appeared as though this was a typical “Act of God” scenario—where the defendant in this case, presumably Southgate College, would reasonably point to the high winds, the number of trees falling throughout Britain, and

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Carey Olsen—Kim Paiva

Carey Olsen—Kim Paiva

Group partner joins Guernsey banking and finance practice

Morgan Lewis—Kat Gibson

Morgan Lewis—Kat Gibson

London labour and employment team announces partner hire

Foot Anstey McKees—Chris Milligan & Michael Kelly

Foot Anstey McKees—Chris Milligan & Michael Kelly

Double partner appointment marks Belfast expansion

NEWS
The Ministry of Justice (MoJ) has not done enough to protect the future sustainability of the legal aid market, MPs have warned
Writing in NLJ this week, NLJ columnist Dominic Regan surveys a landscape marked by leapfrog appeals, costs skirmishes and notable retirements. With an appeal in Mazur due to be heard next month, Regan notes that uncertainties remain over who will intervene, and hopes for the involvement of the Lady Chief Justice and the Master of the Rolls in deciding the all-important outcome
After the Southport murders and the misinformation that followed, contempt of court law has come under intense scrutiny. In this week's NLJ, Lawrence McNamara and Lauren Schaefer of the Law Commission unpack proposals aimed at restoring clarity without sacrificing fair trial rights
The latest Home Office figures confirm that stop and search remains both controversial and diminished. Writing in NLJ this week, Neil Parpworth of De Montfort University analyses data showing historically low use of s 1 PACE powers, with drugs searches dominating what remains
Boris Johnson’s 2019 attempt to shut down Parliament remains a constitutional cautionary tale. The move, framed as a routine exercise of the royal prerogative, was in truth an extraordinary effort to sideline Parliament at the height of the Brexit crisis. Writing in NLJ this week, Professor Graham Zellick KC dissects how prorogation was wrongly assumed to be beyond judicial scrutiny, only for the Supreme Court to intervene unanimously
back-to-top-scroll