header-logo header-logo

19 July 2007 / Andrew Keogh
Issue: 7282 / Categories: Features
printer mail-detail

The justice merry-go-round

The government’s latest criminal justice reforms could be a recipe for disaster, says Andrew Keogh

It is not only the mandated right to legislate that governments enjoy, but also a duty to pass laws that improve the lot of citizens. One must therefore be careful before jumping in to criticise the 68th piece of criminal justice legislation since 1997. The Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill is a mixed bag of reforms with many having the appearance of being designed in haste—always a recipe for disaster as far as criminal justice legislation is concerned.

The impact of the reforms on the legal aid budget is staggering and estimated in the regulatory impact assessment as being in the order of £2m per annum. It remains to be seen, given that the Ministry of Justice is the sponsoring department for the Bill, how this will be funded, except via further cuts in scope of remuneration levels.

SENTENCING AND CONVICTIONS

Part 2 of the Bill deals with sentencing. In reality the Bill simply seeks to correct the perceived mistakes

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Boodle Hatfield—Tom McLaughlin

Boodle Hatfield—Tom McLaughlin

Boodle Hatfield welcomes new employment partner, Tom McLaughlin

Arc Pensions Law—Victoria Thompson-Hill, Jonathan Mason & Georgi Ivanov

Arc Pensions Law—Victoria Thompson-Hill, Jonathan Mason & Georgi Ivanov

National specialist pensions law firm strengthens team with three new appointments

Jurit—Christian Abletshauser

Jurit—Christian Abletshauser

Jurit appoints Christian Abletshauser to lead family law practice

NEWS
Burges Salmon appoints Benn Richards to strengthen Contentious Insolvency offering
A High Court decision has clarified that a home may be unfit for human habitation not only where conditions endanger health or safety, but also where they seriously undermine comfort and convenience

A longer time limit for employment tribunal claims, new charity law thresholds, property tribunal recruitment and appellate guidance on small-claims costs feature in the latest Civil Way round-up

A recent High Court ruling could make issue estoppel considerably more complex in cross-border litigation, requiring parties to consider the foreign law governing the underlying claim
The Supreme Court has overturned Cheshire West’s bright-line test for deprivation of liberty, replacing it with a broader, more contextual assessment that gives greater weight to an individual’s wishes, feelings and apparent consent
back-to-top-scroll