header-logo header-logo

Lady Brownlie win brings clarity to overseas accidents cases

Lady Brownlie, whose husband died on a driving tour organised by Four Seasons Hotel Cairo at Nile Plaza, has won her appeal at the Supreme Court, in a decision that has significant implications for English nationals injured or killed while travelling overseas

Lady Brownlie was on holiday in Egypt with her husband, the international lawyer Sir Ian Brownlie QC, when the crash happened. She was seriously injured, while Sir Ian and Sir Ian’s daughter Rebecca, a children’s nurse, both died. Lady Brownlie issued a claim in contract and tort in England.

Terrence Donovan, partner, Kingsley Napley, who acted for Lady Brownlie, said: ‘This judgment will provide welcome clarity for any other English nationals who have the misfortune to be injured or killed in foreign accidents, and who wish to bring their claims in the English Courts.

‘Lady Brownlie, by her courage and determination, has done a great favour to them, and made an important contribution to English travel law.’

The Supreme Court had previously remitted the case to the High Court after finding the company sued was not the operator of the hotel. Lady Brownlie was allowed to substitute the defendant and serve proceedings on them out of the jurisdiction. The defendant appealed on the basis permission should not have been given to serve the proceedings out of the jurisdiction. However, this was dismissed by the Court of Appeal.

The defendant then raised two issues before the Supreme Court. The first was whether the claims in tort satisfied the requirements of the jurisdictional gateway in the Civil Procedure Rules. The second was whether Lady Brownlie needed to provide evidence of Egyptian law to show her claims had a reasonable prospect of success.

Ruling in FS Cairo (Nile Plaza) LLC v Lady Brownlie [2021] UKSC 45, however, the Supreme Court decided in favour of Lady Brownlie and dismissed the defendant’s appeal by a 4-1 majority. The claim will now return to the High Court.

MOVERS & SHAKERS

DWF—19 appointments

DWF—19 appointments

Belfast team bolstered by three senior hires and 16 further appointments

Cadwalader—Andro Atlaga

Cadwalader—Andro Atlaga

Firm strengthens leveraged finance team with London partner hire

Knights—Ella Dodgson & Rebecca Laffan

Knights—Ella Dodgson & Rebecca Laffan

Double hire marks launch of family team in Leeds

NEWS
Bea Rossetto of the National Pro Bono Centre makes the case for ‘General Practice Pro Bono’—using core legal skills to deliver life-changing support, without the need for niche expertise—in this week's NLJ
Charlie Mercer and Astrid Gillam of Stewarts crunch the numbers on civil fraud claims in the English courts, in this week's NLJ. New data shows civil fraud claims rising steadily since 2014, with the King’s Bench Division overtaking the Commercial Court as the forum of choice for lower-value disputes
Artificial intelligence may be revolutionising the law, but its misuse could wreck cases and careers, warns Clare Arthurs of Penningtons Manches Cooper in this week's NLJ
Small law firms want to embrace technology but feel lost in a maze of jargon, costs and compliance fears, writes Aisling O’Connell of the Solicitors Regulation Authority in this week's NLJ
Writing in NLJ this week, Victoria Rylatt and Robyn Laye of Anthony Gold Solicitors examine recent international relocation cases where allegations of domestic abuse shaped outcomes
back-to-top-scroll