header-logo header-logo

13 February 2019 / Alec Samuels
Issue: 7828 / Categories: Features , Profession
printer mail-detail

Life on the bench

Alec Samuels reflects on bias—especially political bias—in the judiciary

There was a time when, before appointment as a judge, many of the judges had been active in politics, as MPs: Conservative, Liberal and Labour. But according to constitutional convention, following appointment, they showed no political bias in their judicial work. The Lord Chancellor himself was expected to be, and was, and indeed still is, an active politician, albeit restrained; however, he is no longer a judge.

Judicial appointments

Ex Lord Chancellor Dilhorne became a law lord 1969-1980. First Viscount Cave and Lord Mackay were law lords before becoming Lord Chancellor. First Viscounts Maugham and Simmonds were law lords before becoming Lord Chancellor and then again law lords after ceasing to be Lord Chancellor.

Judges who have been MPs include: Simon, Thankerton, Watson, Robson, Macnaghten, Donovan, Shaw, Carson, Cave, Davey, MacDermott and Normand.

Quite a number in addition have been law officers, or the Scottish equivalent: Simon, Somervell, Rodger, Russell, Reid, Carson, Hewart, Cave, Mackay, Macmillan, Singleton and Sir Ross Cranston. And Somervell

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

NLJ Career Profile: Ken Fowlie, Stowe Family Law

NLJ Career Profile: Ken Fowlie, Stowe Family Law

Ken Fowlie, chairman of Stowe Family Law, reflects on more than 30 years in legal services after ‘falling into law’

Gardner Leader—Michelle Morgan & Catherine Morris

Gardner Leader—Michelle Morgan & Catherine Morris

Regional law firm expands employment team with partner and senior associate hires

Freeths—Carly Harwood & Tom Newton

Freeths—Carly Harwood & Tom Newton

Nottinghamtrusts, estates and tax team welcomes two senior associates

NEWS
Children can claim for ‘lost years’ damages in personal injury cases, the Supreme Court has held in a landmark judgment
The cab-rank rule remains a bulwark of the rule of law, yet lawyers are increasingly judged by their clients’ causes. Writing in NLJ this week, Ian McDougall, president of the LexisNexis Rule of Law Foundation, warns that conflating representation with endorsement is a ‘clear and present danger’
Holiday lets may promise easy returns, but restrictive covenants can swiftly scupper plans. Writing in NLJ this week, Andrew Francis of Serle Court recounts how covenants limiting use to a ‘private dwelling house’ or ‘private residence’ have repeatedly defeated short-term letting schemes
Artificial intelligence (AI) is already embedded in the civil courts, but regulation lags behind practice. Writing in NLJ this week, Ben Roe of Baker McKenzie charts a landscape where AI assists with transcription, case management and document handling, yet raises acute concerns over evidence, advocacy and even judgment-writing
The Supreme Court has drawn a firm line under branding creativity in regulated markets. In Dairy UK Ltd v Oatly AB, it ruled that Oatly’s ‘post-milk generation’ trade mark unlawfully deployed a protected dairy designation. In NLJ this week, Asima Rana of DWF explains that the court prioritised ‘regulatory clarity over creative branding choices’, holding that ‘designation’ extends beyond product names to marketing slogans
back-to-top-scroll