header-logo header-logo

The NLJ Column

05 June 2008 / John Cooper KC
Issue: 7324 / Categories: Opinion , Legal services , Procedure & practice , Profession
printer mail-detail

The role of evil in the criminal justice system

It is not unusual to hear the police, judges, journalists or any other interested party, describe the commission of certain crimes as evil. The categories of such offences are well-honed, particularly despicable murder or violence nearly always comes top of the list of evil human behaviour.

More particularly, it is sentenced as such. The judge in his sentencing remarks will refer to the “evil” of the offence, for which a lengthy, condign sentence of imprisonment is the only response.

If the Law Commission's recommendations for the reform of murder become law, the criminal justice system will have to grapple with the concept of first and second degree murder, a conviction for first degree murder—the more heinous category—attracting harsher sentences, entrenching a categorisation approach to crime and sentencing, based at least in part, upon how heinous the offence is.

Evil v Mental Illness

If evil exists as a force which can be quantified, then sending people to prison for committing such crimes should make

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

DWF—Jenny Leonard

DWF—Jenny Leonard

Former Metropolitan Police director joins police, care and justice team

Charles Russell Speechlys—Ed Morgan

Charles Russell Speechlys—Ed Morgan

Corporate real estate and funds expertise expands with partner hire

Hill Dickinson—Helen Foley, Charlotte Fallon & Gary Parnell

Hill Dickinson—Helen Foley, Charlotte Fallon & Gary Parnell

Firm grows London business services team with trio of partner hires

NEWS
AlphaBiolabs has made a £500 donation to Sean’s Place, a men’s mental health charity based in Sefton, as part of its ongoing Giving Back initiative
Human rights lawyers, social justice champion, co-founder of the law firm Bindmans, and NLJ columnist Sir Geoffrey Bindman KC has died at the age of 92 years
RFC Seraing v FIFA, in which the Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU) reaffirmed that awards by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) may be reviewed by EU courts on public-policy grounds, is under examination in this week's NLJ by Dr Estelle Ivanova of Valloni Attorneys at Law, Zurich
Writing in NLJ this week, Sophie Ashcroft and Miranda Joseph of Stevens & Bolton dissect the Privy Council’s landmark ruling in Jardine Strategic Ltd v Oasis Investments II Master Fund Ltd (No 2), which abolishes the long-standing 'shareholder rule'
In NLJ this week, Sailesh Mehta and Theo Burges of Red Lion Chambers examine the government’s first-ever 'Afghan leak' super-injunction—used to block reporting of data exposing Afghans who aided UK forces and over 100 British officials. Unlike celebrity privacy cases, this injunction centred on national security. Its use, the authors argue, signals the rise of a vast new body of national security law spanning civil, criminal, and media domains
back-to-top-scroll