header-logo header-logo

Home Login E-newsletter About us

NLJ this week: AI in the dock—courts need literacy, not fear

© Copyright LexisNexis 2025. All Rights Reserved.
17 October 2025
Issue: 8135 / Categories: Legal News , Artificial intelligence , Technology , Procedure & practice , Regulatory , Litigants in person , Legal services
printer mail-detail
232358
Generative AI isn’t the villain of the courtroom—it’s the misunderstanding of it that’s dangerous, argues Dr Alan Ma of Birmingham City University and the Birmingham Law Society in this week's NLJ

Analysing seven recent cases, including Ayinde, Al-Haroun and Harber, Ma warns that judges are beginning to discount submissions purely because they ‘look like’ they came from ChatGPT. Such suspicion, he says, risks procedural unfairness and chills innovation. While fabricated cases have rightly drawn sanctions, many litigants—especially those in person—are penalised for honest use.

Ma urges regulators and the judiciary to embrace AI literacy, not reflex scepticism, through verification protocols, training, and consistent guidance. His call: regulate and educate, don’t alienate. ‘AI is here to stay,’ he writes, ‘and the courts must learn to live with it.’

Issue: 8135 / Categories: Legal News , Artificial intelligence , Technology , Procedure & practice , Regulatory , Litigants in person , Legal services
printer mail-details
RELATED ARTICLES
 

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Read All
Sponsored by
NLJ Career Profile: Mike Wilson, Blake Morgan

NLJ Career Profile: Mike Wilson, Blake Morgan

Mike Wilson, managing partner of Blake Morgan chair of the CBI’s South-East Council, reflects on his career the challenges that have defined him

Clarke Willmott—Alexandria Kittlety

Clarke Willmott—Alexandria Kittlety

Partner joins commercial property team in Birmingham

Birketts—Will MacFarlane & Sarah Dodds

Birketts—Will MacFarlane & Sarah Dodds

Family team expands with double appointment in Bristol office

NEWS
Read All
Budget shock for pensions
Lawyers have expressed dismay at the Chancellor Rachel Reeve’s decision to impose a £2,000 cap on salary sacrifice contributions
Have your say in NLJ’s annual reader survey
NLJ is inviting its readers to take part in this year’s annual reader research, a short survey designed to help shape the future direction of the magazine. The questionnaire consists of just eight quick questions and offers an opportunity for legal professionals to share their views on the content, coverage and issues that matter most to them.
Pushback on ‘no win no fee’ ban
The Law Society has urged regulators not to ban the term ‘no win no fee’, as the profession contemplates measures to prevent a disaster like the SSB Group collapse from happening again
Jury trials under threat
The legal profession's leaders have mounted a robust defence of trial by jury, following reports that Justice Secretary David Lammy is considering restricting it to rape, murder, manslaughter and other cases that are in the public interest
Mazur appeal to proceed
CILEX (the Chartered Institute of Legal Executives) has been granted permission to appeal Mazur, a decision which has caused consternation among litigation firms
Copyright © 2025 LexisNexis
back-to-top-scroll