Writing in NLJ this week, Rebecca Smart, legal director at Payne Hicks Beach, examines the extensive protections already available, from lifelong anonymity in sexual offence cases to special measures, disclosure restrictions and judicial control of questioning.
The challenge, she argues, often lies in ensuring these safeguards are consistently delivered, alongside clear communication and practical, emotional and therapeutic support.
Defendants must retain a meaningful opportunity to challenge allegations, while questions must serve a legitimate forensic purpose. An acquittal does not establish that a complainant lied; an allegation does not diminish the presumption of innocence.
Before changing the rules, policymakers should establish whether shortcomings reflect inadequate law, underused powers or overstretched services. As Smart cautions: ‘Public concern can expose genuine shortcomings, but urgency is not a substitute for analysis.’




