Writing in NLJ this week, Professor Graham Zellick KC traces the clash between the commission and the Court of Appeal over referrals involving subsequent developments in case law.
He argues that R v Cottrell; R v Fletcher compromised the commission’s independence, while Parliament’s intervention left an uncertain framework tied to the court’s elusive ‘substantial injustice’ test.
With the Law Commission considering reform, Zellick calls for statutory guidance addressing ‘when justice should trump finality’, rather than leaving fundamental policy choices to judges.
He accepts a presumption against revisiting convictions, particularly after death or completion of sentence. However, where a legal development raises substantial doubts about guilt or whether a jury would have convicted, convictions should be set aside. Broad judicial discretion risks leaving substantive miscarriages of justice uncorrected.




