header-logo header-logo

15 May 2008 / Sara Partington , Charlotte Yallop
Issue: 7321 / Categories: Features , Company , Regulatory , Commercial
printer mail-detail

Retain or return?

Sara Partington and Charlotte Yallop revisit the often-ignored law of conversion

The recent High Court case of Schwarzschild v Harrods Ltd [2008] EWHC 521 (QB), [2008] All ER (D) 299 (Mar) has revisited the law of conversion (and its roots alongside detinue) and clarified that, for a cause of action in statutory conversion to arise (and limitation to start to run), both a demand that goods be returned and an unequivocal refusal to return them are required.

The judgment of Mr Justice Eady also sets out a useful review of the law in detinue and in particular the tort of conversion in accordance with the Torts (Interference with Goods) Act 1977 (T(IG)A 1977). It will be of interest to practitioners and to any entity whose business involves bailment or the treatment, dealing in, or retention of goods.

The Facts

In 1955, the defendant contracted with the claimant's mother (M) to rent a safety deposit box for her to store jewellery. Rental payments had ceased

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Clarke Willmott—Alexia Haines & Kelsey Wells

Clarke Willmott—Alexia Haines & Kelsey Wells

Clarke Willmott strengthens Birmingham private client team with double appointment

NLJ Career Profile: Hugo Plowman, Mishcon de Reya

NLJ Career Profile: Hugo Plowman, Mishcon de Reya

From global fraud cases to fishing off-grid, Mishcon de Reya’s chair of dispute resolution Hugo Plowman discusses mentors, management switching off

Maguire Family Law—Jennifer Hudec, Ciara Florey, Alice Ferguson & Ruth Wynn

Maguire Family Law—Jennifer Hudec, Ciara Florey, Alice Ferguson & Ruth Wynn

Maguire Family Law announces partner promotion and new hires amid a record year for enquiries

NEWS
Defendants who make unsupported complaints about their lawyers risk losing legal aid while confiscation proceedings continue without representation
Lawyers advising Russian clients face different sanctions restrictions across the UK, EU and US, despite their shared objective of increasing pressure on Russia
Artificial intelligence does not demand a wholesale rewrite of liability law, argues an article challenging claims that new technology has created an accountability gap
Restrictions on workplace non-disclosure agreements could make settlements slower, more complex and more expensive when reforms expected in 2027 take effect
Private prosecutors face closer scrutiny under Crown Prosecution Service guidance designed to strengthen accountability and consistency when intervention is requested
back-to-top-scroll