header-logo header-logo

A Titanic struggle

21 October 2010 / Hh Judge Platt
Issue: 7438 / Categories: Features , Procedure & practice
printer mail-detail

HH Judge Platt reports on the latest twists in the RTA claims industry

Lawyers who deal with motor accident claim cases will be well aware of the Titanic struggle which has now been raging for years between the motor insurance industry and the providers of vehicles for hire on credit to those whose cars have been damaged in road traffic accidents. Indeed claims for credit hire now form a significant part of the workload of the judges dealing with Fast Track trials.

Ingenious defence lawyers have continued to run various lines of defence against these claims. Equally ingenious claimant’s lawyers have been arguing for hire charges which usually dwarf the modest claims for whiplash injuries and in turn are sometimes dwarfed by the claims for costs. Most of these arguments are fact specific but most have been bitterly contested with what appears to be little sense of proportion on both sides and a surprising lack of realistic Part 36 offers. But these cases also give rise to important issues of law on which the

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Slater Heelis—Chester office

Slater Heelis—Chester office

North West presence strengthened with Chester office launch

Cooke, Young & Keidan—Elizabeth Meade

Cooke, Young & Keidan—Elizabeth Meade

Firm grows commercial disputes expertise with partner promotion

CBI South-East Council—Mike Wilson

CBI South-East Council—Mike Wilson

Blake Morgan managing partner appointed chair of CBI South-East Council

NEWS
The House of Lords has set up a select committee to examine assisted dying, which will delay the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill
The proposed £11bn redress scheme following the Supreme Court’s motor finance rulings is analysed in this week’s NLJ by Fred Philpott of Gough Square Chambers
In this week's issue, Stephen Gold, NLJ columnist and former district judge, surveys another eclectic fortnight in procedure. With humour and humanity, he reminds readers that beneath the procedural dust, the law still changes lives
Generative AI isn’t the villain of the courtroom—it’s the misunderstanding of it that’s dangerous, argues Dr Alan Ma of Birmingham City University and the Birmingham Law Society in this week's NLJ
James Naylor of Naylor Solicitors dissects the government’s plan to outlaw upward-only rent review (UORR) clauses in new commercial leases under Schedule 31 of the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill, in this week's NLJ. The reform, he explains, marks a seismic shift in landlord-tenant power dynamics: rents will no longer rise inexorably, and tenants gain statutory caps and procedural rights
back-to-top-scroll