header-logo header-logo

21 March 2014 / Nigel Jackson
Issue: 7599 / Categories: Features , Commercial
printer mail-detail

Bending the law

web_jackson

Nigel Jackson outlines the far-reaching consequences of Reithatha v Williamson

Those who are familiar with the English civil justice system, may have noticed an alarming trend in certain recent judicial decisions where judges have shown an increasing tendency to bend the law, or misapply the facts to achieve what they consider to be the desired outcome. Most of the judges currently serving in the civil courts are barristers, who have spent their entire careers re-interpreting laws and arguing “facts” in the manner best suited to advance their clients’ cases, but it is important that they discontinue this practice once they have been appointed to a judicial position.

Not only does the practice discredit the English system of civil justice (the misapplication of law or facts by any court is a very serious matter, whether it is intentional or not), but it is also capable of having far-reaching consequences which can have a devastating impact upon vast numbers of people who have no connection at all to the particular facts presented to a judge in any

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

NLJ Career Profile: Nikki Bowker, Devonshires

NLJ Career Profile: Nikki Bowker, Devonshires

Nikki Bowker, head of dispute resolution at Devonshires, on career resilience, diversity in law and channelling Elle Woods when the pressure is on

Ellisons—Sarah Osborne

Ellisons—Sarah Osborne

Leasehold enfranchisement specialist joins residential property team

DWF—Chris Air

DWF—Chris Air

Firm strengthens commercial team in Manchester with partner appointment

NEWS
The government will aim to pass legislation banning leasehold for new flats and capping ground rent, introducing non-compulsory digital ID and creating a ‘duty of candour’ for public servants (also known as the Hillsborough law) in the next Parliament

An Italian financier has lost his bid to block his Australian wife from filing divorce papers in England on the basis it was no longer her domicile of choice

Reforms to the disclosure regime in the business and property courts have not achieved their objectives, lawyers have warned
The Law Society has urged ministers to hold a public consultation on the use of artificial intelligence (AI) in the justice system as a whole
Ministers have proposed bringing inquest work under a single fee scheme for legal help and advocacy legal aid work
back-to-top-scroll