header-logo header-logo

Crown Court exceeded jurisdiction in bail hearing

19 April 2024
Categories: Legal News , In Court , Judicial review
printer mail-detail
A judge at Snaresbrook Crown Court erred in law by hearing a bail appeal when notice had not been served properly, the High Court has held in a legal first

The case, R (on the application of Darykie Ramos Molina) v Snaresbrook Crown Court [2024] EWHC 816 (Admin), marks the first time a claimant has succeeded in a judicial review concerning the Bail (Amendment) Act 1993.

The claimant, Darykie Ramos Molina, was granted conditional bail by Barkingside magistrates’ court. The Crown Prosecution Service sought to appeal but failed to serve written notice within the required two-hour period. Regardless of this, Snaresbrook Crown Court heard the appeal and remanded the claimant in custody.

The claimant brought a judicial review, contending the Crown Court judge exceeded her jurisdiction and erred in law by deciding bail was a matter for her because the case was listed in the Crown Court.

At the judicial review, the High Court granted the claim on all grounds.

In their judgment, handed down last week, Lady Justice Nicola Davies and Mr Justice Bennathan said: ‘The importance which the courts attach to the liberty of the subject is profound.

‘The provisions of the 1993 Act are explicit and are meant to be followed because a failure to do so can lead to a person being wrongly deprived of their liberty. The Crown Court is a creature of statute… in consequence it does not possess an inherent jurisdiction to overturn decisions of the magistrates’ court unless the same is conferred by the specific provisions of a statute.’

The claimant was represented by Canel Halil of Emery Halil and Brown Solicitors, and Alex Benn, Red Lion Chambers.

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Slater Heelis—Oliver Banks

Slater Heelis—Oliver Banks

Manchester firm strengthens Court of Protection expertise with partner hire

Talbots Law—Sara Pickerin & Nicholas Playford

Talbots Law—Sara Pickerin & Nicholas Playford

Agricultural law team expands with senior director appointments

Kingsley Napley—Claire Green

Kingsley Napley—Claire Green

Firm announces appointment of chief legal officer

NEWS
Entries are now open for the 2026 LexisNexis Legal Awards, celebrating achievement and innovation in the law across 24 categories
The London Legal Support Trust (LLST) is calling on the legal community to don aprons and sharpen their pencils for two of its most popular fundraising events—the Great Legal Bake and the Great Legal Quiz. The events, which take place in November, raise vital funds for free legal advice charities across London and the South East
The Ministry of Justice (MoJ) has launched a review of its whiplash policies, including fixed tariffs, statutory definition of the injury, ban on settling cases without medical evidence and small claims limit
Family lawyers have welcomed government plans to repeal the presumption of parental involvement from the Children Act 1989, but emphasised the need for each case to be determined on its facts
Transferring anti-money laundering (AML) and counter-terrorism financing supervision to the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) could create extra paperwork and increase costs for clients, lawyers have warned 
back-to-top-scroll