header-logo header-logo

28 January 2010 / Nicholas Dobson
Issue: 7402 / Categories: Features , Public
printer mail-detail

A fine distinction

When you “notify” do you also “inform”? asks Nicholas Dobson

Why would people spend good money in getting lawyers to argue for them over the meaning of words? Are they all practising pedants?

Not at all. For if “equity does nothing in vain” neither will most litigants. There will usually be some fundamental and serious issue riding on disputed interpretations of words. And so there was in the Court of Appeal last October where the legal meaning of the words “inform” and “notify” came up for scrutiny in the context of homelessness law (see Ali v. Birmingham City Council [2009] EWCA Civ 1279).

This is in the Housing Act 1996 (HA 1996), pt 7. In particular, s 193 imposes a duty on local housing authorities to secure that accommodation is available for a homeless applicant where the authority is satisfied that the applicant is homeless, eligible for assistance, has a priority need and is not satisfied that the applicant became homeless intentionally. However, under s 193(5) an authority ceases to be subject to this

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

NLJ Career Profile: Maryam Syed KC, Church Court Chambers

NLJ Career Profile: Maryam Syed KC, Church Court Chambers

From childhood dreams of the Bar to some of the country's most challenging cases, Maryam Syed KC explains why she has never stopped standing up for others

DAC Beachcroft—Richard Breavington, Rachel Ford & Daniel Guilfoyle

DAC Beachcroft—Richard Breavington, Rachel Ford & Daniel Guilfoyle

DAC Beachcroft significantly expands Cyber team, hiring three Cyber partners

Browne Jacobson—Professor Clive Kay

Browne Jacobson—Professor Clive Kay

Browne Jacobson appoints senior healthcare leader Professor Clive Kay as strategic adviser

NEWS
As family justice moves further away from the courtroom, collaborative law is emerging as an increasingly important route to resolving separation disputes
A busy period for employment law is producing important lessons for employers, employees and tribunals alike
From forgotten interest claims to case-management appeals, a string of procedural developments offers useful—and occasionally cautionary—lessons for practitioners

Jonathan Fisher KC highlights that it now accounts for around 40% of criminal offences, with roughly 70% involving technology, and argues that the UK cannot simply prosecute its way out of the problem. Detection, investigation and prosecution all require improvement, while different fraud types demand tailored responses.

How forcefully can a litigant criticise a public authority before robust advocacy crosses the line into unreasonable conduct? 
back-to-top-scroll