header-logo header-logo

24 March 2023 / David Langwallner
Issue: 8018 / Categories: Features , Profession , Commercial
printer mail-detail

Frustration by impossibility: come hell or high water

115792
What would Denning do? David Langwallner reports on frustration by impossibility in modern contract law

Lord Denning was, of course, the greatest of all contractual lawyers, and mitigated the excesses of the law of contract.

This law is primarily individualistic and commercial, with occasional concessions to non-market sensibilities. Lord Denning, in contrast, was the great stalwart of innovation in contract, and by promissory estoppel in particular prevented in effect inequitable contracts and promises from being enforced where there was a state of exceptionalism, such as life during wartime (Central London Property Trust Ltd v High Trees House Ltd [1947] KB 130).

What applies where an unforeseen event makes performance of the contract impossible? And how should a Denning-esque judge react to our present situation? The recent jurisprudential record is not good.

Emergency situations

The doctrine of frustration of contract is designed to cope with emergency situations. In doctrinal terms, if a contract is frustrated, it effectively comes to an end and the parties are released

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Walkers—Muriel Marseille

Walkers—Muriel Marseille

Ashurst's Chief Risk Officer joins Walkers

Excello Law—John Osborne

Excello Law—John Osborne

Northern family lawyer John Osborne joins Excello

mfg Solicitors—Rebecca Rogers, Kennedy Langley & Victoria Griffiths

mfg Solicitors—Rebecca Rogers, Kennedy Langley & Victoria Griffiths

Trio of promotions announced at Kidderminster law firm mfg Solicitors

NEWS
A sole director can conspire with their own company for the purposes of the tort of unlawful means conspiracy, the High Court has ruled in a judgment with potentially wide implications for business disputes
The Court of Appeal has reinforced that domicile depends on intention rather than residence alone, in a significant post-Brexit ruling on cross-border financial remedy claims
The Chancery Division's long history comes to an end this autumn as it is reborn as the Business and Property Division, prompting questions over whether the shake-up is really necessary
The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) continues to show that failing to disclose regulatory issues can attract harsher consequences than the original misconduct itself
Rejecting a generous settlement can prove an expensive mistake, as two recent high-profile cases demonstrate
back-to-top-scroll