header-logo header-logo

10 October 2013
Issue: 7579 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-detail

High Court makes important decision on proportionality

Coulson J declines “unreasonable” costs budgets in professional negligence claim 

The High Court has declined to accept “unreasonable” costs budgets on both sides of a £1.6m professional negligence claim, in an important decision on proportionality.

In Willis v MRJ Rundell [2013] EWHC 2923 (TCC), a claim against a firm of construction professionals, both sides submitted their costs budgets in December 2012—£821,000 for the claimants, and £616,000 for the defendants. Mr Justice Coulson expressed concern that the figures were high.

The case went to mediation and the trial was adjourned. Coulson J then ordered a case management hearing solely on costs management, by which time the combined budgets exceeded £1.6m.

Coulson J declined to approve the budgets, stating: “It seems to me that one test of proportionality is whether the trial is likely to be an end in itself, or merely a lesser part of the process, which the parties will use in order to put themselves in the strongest position to argue that, subsequently, the other side should pay all or most of their costs. 

“When the costs on each side are much higher than the amount claimed/recovered, the latter is almost inevitable. I have no doubt that that will be the case here. For those reasons, therefore, I conclude that the costs shown in the costs budgets are disproportionate and unreasonable.”

Coulson J was critical of some of the items on the claimant’s budget, which were “said to be both incurred and estimated, without it being clear which is which, and without any breakdown of either”. 

The allowance for experts’ fees were put at £100,000 “before any account is taken of their involvement at the trial…I would have expected to see a figure something like half the amount actually included in the costs budget,” he said. “Unhappily, my recent experience is that the amount of the experts’ fees in cases like this is often out of all proportion to the assistance provided.”

However, practitioners will be relieved by Coulson J’s comments that the absence of an approved budget do not necessarily mean no costs are recoverable.

Issue: 7579 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-details

MOVERS & SHAKERS

NLJ Career Profile: Suzanne Todd, Withers

NLJ Career Profile: Suzanne Todd, Withers

From ERASMUS in Modena to the presidency of the International Academy of Family Lawyers, Withers partner Suzanne Todd reflects on her career and the changing face of flexible working

Mackrell LLP—Anest Mathias

Mackrell LLP—Anest Mathias

Mackrell LLP strengthens family team with leading fertility and surrogacy lawyer Anest Mathias

Meaby & Co—Daniel Bolster

Meaby & Co—Daniel Bolster

Meaby Co strengthens litigation and disputes team with appointment of Daniel Bolster

NEWS
Good news! The deadline for entries to the LexisNexis Legal Awards 2027 has been extended to Friday 27 November 2026, giving you more time to showcase your achievements and receive the recognition you deserve
Young people would be given a legal right to education, training or work, under former minister Alan Milburn’s proposals to help NEETs (those not in education, employment, or training)
All women convicted or cautioned for abortion offences relating to their own pregnancy have been automatically pardoned and will have their criminal records wiped clean
Bar Council chair Kirsty Brimelow KC has highlighted that barristers already undertake specific training on rape and serious sexual offences, vulnerable witnesses and trauma-informed practice, in response to concerns raised over the Russell Brand trial
The Law Society has called for more investment in the courts following a surge of private landlord possession claims, the first step towards eviction under the Renters’ Rights Act 2026, which abolished section 21 ‘no fault’ eviction
back-to-top-scroll