Writing in NLJ this week, Sophie Houghton, knowledge lawyer at Lexis+ UK Dispute Resolution, surveys rulings covering dishonest conduct, small claims, assessment proceedings, delegated litigation work and judicial discretion.
The usual starting point remains that the unsuccessful party pays, but misconduct can justify reducing or withholding recovery. Any departure requires a balanced assessment and proportionate consequences, including consideration of both parties’ behaviour.
Elsewhere, discontinuing a small claim close to trial does not, without more, establish unreasonable conduct, while solicitor–client assessments cannot become investigations into suspected secret insurance commissions outside their scope.
Houghton also considers supervision following Mazur and the demanding threshold for challenging case management decisions.
Her practical message is to get costs arguments right first time: ‘disagreement with the outcome alone will rarely be enough’ to secure appellate intervention.




