header-logo header-logo

Parliamentary privilege abused

12 September 2025 / Dr Graham Zellick CBE KC FAcSS
Issue: 8130 / Categories: Opinion , Legal services , Constitutional law
printer mail-detail
229571
Professor Graham Zellick KC questions why parliamentarians are able to misuse their immunity with impunity

I have little in common with the shopkeeper and businessman Sir Philip Green, but one thing we do share is that we have both been the victim of an abuse of parliamentary privilege.

The circumstances were very different, however. One case concerned the disclosure of a truth suppressed by court order; the other the promulgation of a deliberate lie. In Green’s case, his name was revealed in the House of Lords contrary to the terms of an interim injunction and anonymity order issued by the Court of Appeal, designed to protect his reputation pending trial of a civil action. In my case, a member of Parliament (whom I prefer not to name, allowing him to rest in well-earned obscurity) simply told a lie about me that amounted to a serious attack on my professional integrity. Neither the peer nor the late MP suffered any sanctions or consequences.

Green took his case to the

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Red Lion Chambers—Maurice MacSweeney

Red Lion Chambers—Maurice MacSweeney

Set creates new client and business development role amid growth

Kingsley Napley—Tim Lowles

Kingsley Napley—Tim Lowles

Sports disputes practice launchedwith partner appointment

mfg Solicitors—Tom Evans

mfg Solicitors—Tom Evans

Tax and succession planning offering expands with returning partner

NEWS
The rank of King’s Counsel (KC) has been awarded to 96 barristers, and no solicitors, in the latest silk round
Can a chief constable be held responsible for disobedient officers? Writing in NLJ this week, Neil Parpworth, professor of public law at De Montfort University, examines a Court of Appeal ruling that answers firmly: yes
Early determination is no longer a novelty in arbitration. In NLJ this week, Gustavo Moser, arbitration specialist lawyer at Lexis+, charts the global embrace of summary disposal powers, now embedded in the Arbitration Act 1996 and mirrored worldwide. Tribunals may swiftly dismiss claims with ‘no real prospect of succeeding’, but only if fairness is preserved
The Ministry of Justice is once again in the dock as access to justice continues to deteriorate. NLJ consultant editor David Greene warns in this week's issue that neither public legal aid nor private litigation funding looks set for a revival in 2026
Civil justice lurches onward with characteristic eccentricity. In his latest Civil Way column, Stephen Gold, NLJ columnist, surveys a procedural landscape featuring 19-page bundle rules, digital possession claims, and rent laws he labels ‘bonkers’
back-to-top-scroll