header-logo header-logo

21 July 2016
Issue: 7708 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-detail

Patel v Mirza: restitution ordered by Supreme Court despite insider dealing plan

A man who gave another man £620,000 to buy shares on the basis of insider knowledge was entitled to claim his money back when the shares were not bought.

In Patel v Mirza [2016] UKSC 42, Patel gave Mirza £620,000 to buy shares in a bank because Mirza expected his contacts to inform him of a government announcement about the bank. However, the insider dealing plan fell through when Mirza’s contacts did not deliver. Mirza kept the money. Patel sued. The issue was at what point involvement in illegality bars a claim.

Nine justices of the Supreme Court upheld the Court of Appeal’s decision that Mirza must pay the money back.

Lord Mansfield said in the 1775 case of Holman v Johnson 1 Cowp 341 that “no court will lend its aid to a man who founds his cause of action upon an immoral or an illegal act”. In this week’s judgment, however, the Supreme Court said various factors are relevant when assessing whether it would be disproportionate to refuse relief. These include: the seriousness of the conduct, its centrality to the contract, whether it was intentional and whether there was marked disparity in the parties’ respective culpability.

Delivering the lead judgment, Lord Toulson said: “A claimant, such as Mr Patel, who satisfies the ordinary requirements of a claim for unjust enrichment, should not be debarred from enforcing his claim by reason only of the fact that the money which he seeks to recover was paid for an unlawful purpose. There may be rare cases where for some particular reason the enforcement of such a claim might be regarded as undermining the integrity of the justice system, but there are no such circumstances in this case.”

Lord Sumption said: “The courts will not give effect to an illegal transaction or to a right derived from it. But restitution does not do that.”

Issue: 7708 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-details

MOVERS & SHAKERS

NLJ Career Profile: Suzanne Todd, Withers

NLJ Career Profile: Suzanne Todd, Withers

From ERASMUS in Modena to the presidency of the International Academy of Family Lawyers, Withers partner Suzanne Todd reflects on her career and the changing face of flexible working

Mackrell LLP—Anest Mathias

Mackrell LLP—Anest Mathias

Mackrell LLP strengthens family team with leading fertility and surrogacy lawyer Anest Mathias

Meaby & Co—Daniel Bolster

Meaby & Co—Daniel Bolster

Meaby Co strengthens litigation and disputes team with appointment of Daniel Bolster

NEWS
Good news! The deadline for entries to the LexisNexis Legal Awards 2027 has been extended to Friday 27 November 2026, giving you more time to showcase your achievements and receive the recognition you deserve
Young people would be given a legal right to education, training or work, under former minister Alan Milburn’s proposals to help NEETs (those not in education, employment, or training)
All women convicted or cautioned for abortion offences relating to their own pregnancy have been automatically pardoned and will have their criminal records wiped clean
Bar Council chair Kirsty Brimelow KC has highlighted that barristers already undertake specific training on rape and serious sexual offences, vulnerable witnesses and trauma-informed practice, in response to concerns raised over the Russell Brand trial
The Law Society has called for more investment in the courts following a surge of private landlord possession claims, the first step towards eviction under the Renters’ Rights Act 2026, which abolished section 21 ‘no fault’ eviction
back-to-top-scroll