R (on the application of Mackaill and others) v Independent Police Complaints Commission [2014] EWHC 3170 (Admin), [2014] All ER (D) 52 (Oct)
In the course of litigation following “Plebgate”, the claimant police officers sought judicial review of the Independent Police Complaints Commission’s decision to re-determine the mode of investigation of them. The Divisional Court found that, as a result of procedural irregularities, the report of the original investigation had been invalid and of no effect. The argument that the power to re-determine the mode of investigation had not been available could not succeed, but there had been apparent bias or predetermination in that decision.
