header-logo header-logo

Secret detentions at port ruled unlawful

07 June 2023
Issue: 8028 / Categories: Legal News , Immigration & asylum , National Health Service
printer mail-detail
A secret policy used by the home secretary to repeatedly stop and detain two mothers and their young children at port has been declared unlawful by the High Court.

The women, represented by Bhatt Murphy Solicitors, are foreign nationals with leave to remain in the UK, have children who were born in the UK, and have outstanding NHS debt dating back to a time when their immigration status meant they had to pay for medical treatment. The policy was uncovered through evidence gathered from charities and lawyers.

In R (MXK and others) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2023] EWHC 1272 (Admin), the court heard evidence gathered from charities and lawyers about an unpublished Home Office policy to detain at the border those with continuing leave to remain and NHS debt. Individuals were questioned about their debt for several hours. This was despite the fact the debt has no relevance to the individual’s re-entry to the UK.

The home secretary initially denied the policy existed, but later disclosed the policy during the course of the litigation, although she denied the policy should have been published.

Delivering judgment, Mr Justice Chamberlain held the women and young children were falsely imprisoned by the home secretary without justification. He held the home secretary had breached her duty to consider the impact of the policy on protected groups, including women, who are known to be disproportionately affected by NHS charging.

Chamberlain J said: ‘The fact that the policy is unpublished supplies a further reason why it is unlawful.’

Janet Farrell, partner at Bhatt Murphy, said: ‘The detention of our clients was humiliating and distressing.

‘This judgment shows how vital it is that policies concerning the use of coercive powers such as detention are published so victims can hold the government to account in court in a meaningful way.’ 

MOVERS & SHAKERS

NLJ Career Profile: Maria Karaiskos KC, Church Court Chambers

NLJ Career Profile: Maria Karaiskos KC, Church Court Chambers

Maria Karaiskos KC, recently appointed as the first female head of Church Court Chambers, discusses breaking down barriers, the lure of the courtroom, and the power of storytelling

Cripps—Simon Main

Cripps—Simon Main

Firm strengthens residential property team with partner hire

Hugh James—Danielle Cahill

Hugh James—Danielle Cahill

Private wealth disputes team welcomes partner in London

NEWS
In a very special tribute in this week's NLJ, David Burrows reflects on the retirement of Patrick Allen, co-founder of Hodge Jones & Allen, whose career epitomised the heyday of legal aid
Writing in NLJ this week, Kelvin Rutledge KC of Cornerstone Barristers and Genevieve Screeche-Powell of Field Court Chambers examine the Court of Appeal’s rejection of a discrimination challenge to Tower Hamlets’ housing database
Michael Zander KC, Emeritus Professor at LSE, tracks the turbulent passage of the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill through the House of Lords in this week's issue of NLJ. Two marathon debates drew contributions from nearly 200 peers, split between support, opposition and conditional approval
Alistair Mills of Landmark Chambers reflects on the Human Rights Act 1998 a quarter-century after it came into force, in this week's issue of NLJ
In his latest Civil Way column for NLJ, Stephen Gold surveys a raft of procedural changes and quirky disputes shaping civil practice. His message is clear: civil practitioners must brace for continual tweaks, unexpected contentions and rising costs in everyday litigation
back-to-top-scroll