header-logo header-logo

Sheepish behaviour

29 May 2008 / Charles Foster
Issue: 7323 / Categories: Features , Public , Human rights , Constitutional law
printer mail-detail

Charles Foster reflects on the disappointing nature of the debate on the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill

In last week's debate on the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill there was much sound and much fury. What does it signify?

The outcomes (no to a reduction in the 24-week limit for “social abortions”; yes to animal-human hybrid embryos; yes to 'true hybrids' created by fusion of an animal gamete and a human gamete; yes to saviour siblings; and no to a requirement to consider the need for a father when considering IVF) have been headline news. The standard of debate in the broadsheets has been high. There is no point in reiterating the arguments for and against each issue. Most thinking people will have felt either happy or sad when they heard the result of each of the votes. Indifference isn't an intelligent option.

But surely, whatever one's stance on these technically difficult and heartbreaking issues, there must be deep dismay at the way they were handled by our elected representatives. There was a

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Carey Olsen—Jeremy Lightfoot

Carey Olsen—Jeremy Lightfoot

Dispute resolution partner joins Jersey office from Hong Kong

Constantine Law—Vivien Cochrane

Constantine Law—Vivien Cochrane

Agile employment and regulatory firm welcomes partner

Twenty Essex—four members

Twenty Essex—four members

Chambers welcomes four new tenants following successful pupillage

NEWS
The long-awaited Hillsborough Law—creating a legal duty of candour on public authorities and officials—has been introduced in Parliament
The current ‘postcode lottery’ of support for more than half a million disabled children in England could be replaced with clearer rights and national eligibility criteria, under Law Commission proposals
Face-scanning artificial intelligence (AI) surveillance tech is to be used to remotely monitor offenders, under a Home Office pilot
Proposed tax adviser legislation is so broad it would cover ‘conveyancers filling out stamp duty land tax returns’, Law Society president Richard Atkinson has warned
UK legal sector revenue grew 7.86% in July to £4.87bn, outperforming the services sector as a whole, which was only 0.3% higher at £249bn
back-to-top-scroll