header-logo header-logo

The capacity jigsaw

26 September 2019 / Chris Williams
Issue: 7857 / Categories: Features , Wills & Probate , Mental health
printer mail-detail
Chris Williams provides an update on the evidence & standard of proof required to gauge mental capacity
  • Mental capacity, whether capacity to exercise power of amendment of trust deed.
  • The level of understanding required depends on the circumstances of each case.

Whether or not a person has the requisite mental capacity to exercise a power under a trust deed is often not easy to establish. The Grand Court of the Cayman Islands had to consider this question recently in CI Trustees Ltd v RDK & GMB (2018) FSD 199 of 2015(IKJ) and the case provides useful guidance as to the standard of proof, evidence and other relevant considerations required to determine the question, often in circumstances where facts and circumstances are case specific.

Facts

Proceedings in CI Trustees Ltd v RDK and GMB (2018) FSD 199 of 2015(IKJ) Grand Court of the Cayman Islands (FSD) were started by the trustee on 9 December 2015 to determine who was the true beneficiary of a trust (the O Trust) declared by the settlor.

  • The
If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

NLJ Career Profile: Kadie Bennett, Anthony Collins

NLJ Career Profile: Kadie Bennett, Anthony Collins

Kadie Bennett, senior associate at Anthony Collins and chair of the Resolution West Midlands Group, discusses her long-standing passion for family law and calls for unity in the profession

Osborne Clarke—Lara Burch

Osborne Clarke—Lara Burch

Firm appoints new UK senior partner for 2026

Keoghs—Louise Jackson & Katie Everson

Keoghs—Louise Jackson & Katie Everson

Healthcare and sports legal team expands in the north west

NEWS
Lawyers and users of the business and property courts are invited to share their views on disclosure, in particular the operation of PD 57AD and the use of Technology Assisted Review (TAR) and artificial intelligence (AI)
Social media giants should face tortious liability for the psychological harms their platforms inflict, argues Harry Lambert of Outer Temple Chambers in this week’s NLJ
Ian Gascoigne of LexisNexis dissects the uneasy balance between open justice and confidentiality in England’s civil courts, in this week's NLJ. From public hearings to super-injunctions, he identifies five tiers of privacy—from fully open proceedings to entirely secret ones—showing how a patchwork of exceptions has evolved without clear design
The Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024—once heralded as a breakthrough—has instead plunged leaseholders into confusion, warns Shabnam Ali-Khan of Russell-Cooke in this week’s NLJ
The Employment Appeal Tribunal has now confirmed that offering a disabled employee a trial period in an alternative role can itself be a 'reasonable adjustment' under the Equality Act 2010: in this week's NLJ, Charles Pigott of Mills & Reeve analyses the evolving case law
back-to-top-scroll