header-logo header-logo

10 November 2016 / Dr Jon Robins
Issue: 7722 / Categories: Opinion , Brexit , EU
printer mail-detail

Too little, too late

nlj_7722_robins

The lord chancellor’s response to the attacks on judicial independence has not found favour with the legal profession, notes Jon Robins

“Derry Irvine would have gone ballistic.” So tweeted the former Labour MP and barrister David Lock QC about the seeming equanimity of our present lord chancellor at the series of vicious and personal press attacks on our judiciary following the ruling of the High Court on the Art 50 litigation.

The Daily Mail’s shocking headline read “Enemies of the people” over enormous pictures of the three judges presiding over the case: the lord chief justice, Lord Thomas, Lord Justice Sales and Master of the Rolls Sir Terence Etherton.

A number of commentators noted that the Mail’s front page shared the same headline, as well as an uncanny and disturbing similarity, with a 1933 German newspaper berating judges, also pictured, for attempting to defeat the “common will of the German people”. The Telegraph opted for a no less incendiary headline—“The judges versus the people”—and again ran photographs of the judicial trio prominently

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

42BR Barristers—4 Brick Court

42BR Barristers—4 Brick Court

42BR Barristers to be joined by leading family law set, 4 Brick Court, this summer

Winckworth Sherwood—Rubianka Winspear

Winckworth Sherwood—Rubianka Winspear

Real estate and construction energy offering boosted by partner hire

Gateley Legal—Daniel Walsh

Gateley Legal—Daniel Walsh

Firm bolsters real estate team with partner hire in Birmingham

NEWS
A wave of housing and procedural reforms is set to test the limits of tribunal capacity. In his latest Civil Way column for NLJ this week, Stephen Gold charts sweeping change as the Renters’ Rights Act 2025 begins biting
Plans to reduce jury trials risk missing the real problem in the criminal justice system. Writing in NLJ this week, David Wolchover of Ridgeway Chambers argues the crown court backlog is fuelled not by juries but weak cases slipping through a flawed ‘50%’ prosecution test
Emerging technologies may soon transform how courts determine truth in deeply personal disputes. In this week's NLJ, Madhavi Kabra of 1 Hare Court and Harry Lambert of Outer Temple Chambers explore how neurotechnology could reshape family law
A controversial protest case has reignited debate over the limits of free expression. In NLJ this week, Nicholas Dobson examines a Quran-burning incident testing public order law
The courts have drawn a firm line under attempts to extend arbitration appeals. Writing in NLJ this week, Masood Ahmed of the University of Leicester highlights that if the High Court refuses permission under s 68 of the Arbitration Act 1996, that is the end
back-to-top-scroll