header-logo header-logo

Welcome ruling on ATE

04 June 2015
Issue: 7655 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-detail

ATE premium for clinical negligence recoverable in full

A £5,680 after-the-event (ATE) insurance premium for an indemnity of £10,000 can be recovered in a clinical negligence case, the High Court has ruled.

Master Leonard in the Senior Court Cost Office held in favour of insurers Temple Legal Protection that its ATE premium for clinical negligence was neither unreasonable in amount nor disproportionate and was recoverable in full, in Nokes v Heart of England Foundation Trust (2015) SCCO Ref: CL 1404886.

The claimant took out the insurance policy regarding export reports into liability and causation for her clinical negligence claim.

ATE premiums have been irrecoverable apart from in certain clinical negligence cases since 1 April 2013, when the Legal Aid Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 (LASPO) came into force.

Master Leonard found the policy was fully compliant with the statutory requirements and the premium of £5,680 plus insurance premium tax was reasonable and proportionate.

David Pipkin, director, underwriting division at Temple, gave evidence that the ATE insurance market changed post-LASPO, and Temple developed an underwriting model that provided cover for a “basket” of cases which met certain criteria without the extra burden of assessing and setting a bespoke premium for each case.

Patrick Allen, senior partner at Hodge, Jones and Allen, says: “Without ATE insurance to cover expert reports, most clinical negligence clients would be deterred from investigating claims. A viable insurance product for this risk was therefore vital to make the new CFA regime work. The decision means that insurers such as Temple can continue to offer cover and claimants will have the comfort of knowing that insurance is available.”

 
Issue: 7655 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-details

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Slater Heelis—Chester office

Slater Heelis—Chester office

North West presence strengthened with Chester office launch

Cooke, Young & Keidan—Elizabeth Meade

Cooke, Young & Keidan—Elizabeth Meade

Firm grows commercial disputes expertise with partner promotion

CBI South-East Council—Mike Wilson

CBI South-East Council—Mike Wilson

Blake Morgan managing partner appointed chair of CBI South-East Council

NEWS
The House of Lords has set up a select committee to examine assisted dying, which will delay the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill
The proposed £11bn redress scheme following the Supreme Court’s motor finance rulings is analysed in this week’s NLJ by Fred Philpott of Gough Square Chambers
In this week's issue, Stephen Gold, NLJ columnist and former district judge, surveys another eclectic fortnight in procedure. With humour and humanity, he reminds readers that beneath the procedural dust, the law still changes lives
Generative AI isn’t the villain of the courtroom—it’s the misunderstanding of it that’s dangerous, argues Dr Alan Ma of Birmingham City University and the Birmingham Law Society in this week's NLJ
James Naylor of Naylor Solicitors dissects the government’s plan to outlaw upward-only rent review (UORR) clauses in new commercial leases under Schedule 31 of the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill, in this week's NLJ. The reform, he explains, marks a seismic shift in landlord-tenant power dynamics: rents will no longer rise inexorably, and tenants gain statutory caps and procedural rights
back-to-top-scroll