header-logo header-logo

Abandon clinical negligence costs reforms, government told

27 April 2022
Issue: 7976 / Categories: Legal News , Personal injury
printer mail-detail
Proposed clinical negligence costs reforms are ‘unfair’ to injured patients and families of patients who have died, and would act as a barrier to access to justice, personal injury lawyers have warned

The Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) consultation, Fixed recoverable costs in lower value clinical negligence claims, closed this week. It proposed a streamlined process for claims valued up to £25,000, with limits at each stage on the amount of legal costs that successful claimants can recover.

Responding, the Association of Costs Lawyers (ACL) said the proposed pre-action track should go ahead as this would achieve the objective of reducing costs, but the plans for fixed recoverable should be dropped.

ACL Council member Kris Kilsby said: ‘Fixed recoverable costs are a very blunt instrument that may work in areas where the course of claims is relatively predictable―such as road traffic accidents―but not in a much more complex area like clinical negligence.’

If the government did decide to go ahead, however, the ACL questioned the level of costs and noted the consultation failed to provide ‘any form of reasoning’. It urged a ‘full and proper costs analysis’ before the final fixed recoverable costs were decided.

Qamar Anwar, managing director of independent legal marketing collective First4Lawyers, urged the government to ditch the whole plan, warning ‘low value does not mean simple’.

Moreover, the proposals could backfire, with litigants in person trying to being unmeritorious claims, costing the NHS more in legal spend. He said the government’s plans to introduce mandatory neutral evaluation, with specialist barristers evaluating claims at the outset, could lead to longer delays for consumers.

Suzanne Trask, Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (Apil) executive committee member, said: ‘Subjecting vulnerable injured patients, who lack the capacity to bring their own claims, to this pared down process is unfair and inconsistent.’
Issue: 7976 / Categories: Legal News , Personal injury
printer mail-details

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Thomson Hayton Winkley—Suzie Fisher

Thomson Hayton Winkley—Suzie Fisher

Cumbria firm appoints long-serving lawyer as new managing director

Taylor Wessing—Kim Wedral

Taylor Wessing—Kim Wedral

Employment specialist joins Cambridge office as partner

Mewburn Ellis—Amy Crouch

Mewburn Ellis—Amy Crouch

Patent litigation offering boosted by partner appointment

NEWS
The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) has published a statement in a bid to clear up confusion over the right to conduct litigation following Mazur and another v Charles Russell Speechleys
Homebuyers could be given an option to sign a binding contract with vendors to protect against the practice of parties pulling out of agreements after months of negotiations, under a proposed overhaul of conveyancing laws
A future Conservative government would abolish the Sentencing Council and Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) and sack judges who defended migrants’ rights, shadow justice secretary Robert Jenrick has said
UK law firms have risen up an annual index of responsible business activity, while US firms have regressed amid President Trump’s diversity and equality crackdown
The right of the press to report on the criminal courts received a boost this week, following an update to the Criminal Procedure Rules
back-to-top-scroll