header-logo header-logo

Banks not liable for APP fraud

12 July 2023
Issue: 8033 / Categories: Legal News , Fraud , Commercial
printer mail-detail
Banks do not owe a Quincecare duty to individual customers, the Supreme Court has held unanimously in Barclays Bank UK v Philipp [2023] UKSC 25

The case arose from an authorised push payment (APP) fraud perpetrated by a third-party, which tricked Mrs Philipp and her husband into transferring £700,000 to fraudsters in the UAE. She sued Barclays for not exercising reasonable care and skill and for breaching its Quincecare duty, which requires a bank to stop a payment if it suspects attempted misappropriation of funds.

Lorna Bramich, senior associate, Taylor Wessing, said the Quincecare duty ‘was established over 30 years ago and from the handful of cases since, it was thought that the duty applied to corporate customers only, where an agent of a corporate entity (for example, company director) issues a payment instruction as part of a fraud on the company.

‘The Supreme Court has clarified that the duty is limited to these situations. The rationale for it arising in such situations is because the customer has given an agent authority to make a payment on its behalf and that authority could not be said to include acting dishonestly. Where an individual customer gives the payment instruction, the validity of the instruction is not in doubt’.

Simon Fawell, partner at Signature Litigation, said ‘This brings to an end a recent line of cases which have suggested a widening of the Quincecare principle and, while entirely sound in its reasoning, reduces the avenues through which victims of fraud might recover their losses.

‘Perhaps the biggest gap for victims of fraud currently is that claims against a fraudster's bank remain difficult under English law, notwithstanding the measures in place requiring banks to diligence their customers and monitor for potentially fraudulent activity.’

Gerard Heyes, partner at Farrer & Co, said there are ‘ongoing efforts by government and regulators to see that the banks play a central role in the prevention of APP fraud and the reimbursement of victims’.

David Greene, NLJ consultant editor and head of Class Action and Finance Litigation at Edwin Coe, said: ‘The banks will breathe a sigh of relief that the Quincecare liability has been restricted only to the circumstances when the fraudster acting ostensibly as the victim’s agent instructs the bank to make a payment from the victims account, and not the much wider liability determined by the Court of Appeal where the victim themselves give the instruction.

 ‘The one glimmer of hope for the claimant is that her case that the bank should have acted sooner to undo the payment remains an issue to be tried.’

Issue: 8033 / Categories: Legal News , Fraud , Commercial
printer mail-details

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Gilson Gray—Linda Pope

Gilson Gray—Linda Pope

Partner joins family law team inLondon

Jackson Lees Group—five promotions

Jackson Lees Group—five promotions

Private client division announces five new partners

Taylor Wessing—Max Millington

Taylor Wessing—Max Millington

Banking and finance team welcomes partner in London

NEWS
The landmark Supreme Court’s decision in Johnson v FirstRand Bank Ltd—along with Rukhadze v Recovery Partners—redefine fiduciary duties in commercial fraud. Writing in NLJ this week, Mary Young of Kingsley Napley analyses the implications of the rulings
Barristers Ben Keith of 5 St Andrew’s Hill and Rhys Davies of Temple Garden Chambers use the arrest of Simon Leviev—the so-called Tinder Swindler—to explore the realities of Interpol red notices, in this week's NLJ
Mazur v Charles Russell Speechlys [2025] has upended assumptions about who may conduct litigation, warn Kevin Latham and Fraser Barnstaple of Kings Chambers in this week's NLJ. But is it as catastrophic as first feared?
Lord Sales has been appointed to become the Deputy President of the Supreme Court after Lord Hodge retires at the end of the year
Limited liability partnerships (LLPs) are reportedly in the firing line in Chancellor Rachel Reeves upcoming Autumn budget
back-to-top-scroll