header-logo header-logo

Closing down sale

31 March 2011 / Catherine Urquhart , Johnathan Payne
Issue: 7459 / Categories: Features
printer mail-detail
istock_000014310965small1_4

Does Edwards-Tubb mark the end of “expert shopping”, ask Johnathan Payne & Catherine Urquhart

Judges have long expressed the view that the practice of “expert shopping” goes against the spirit of the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), under which parties are encouraged to adopt a “cards on the table” approach to pre-action conduct and litigation.

Nevertheless, some claimants obtain a report from expert A under the pre-action protocol but then decide not to rely upon it and instead put forward a report from expert B. The defendant, unsurprisingly, then tends to be more suspicious of expert B and consequently becomes less likely to settle, thus thwarting the intention of the pre-action protocol.

This essentially was the situation that arose in Edwards-Tubb v JD Wetherspoon PLC [2011] EWCA Civ 136, [2011] All ER (D) 276 (Feb) and the Court of Appeal unanimously held that if a party wishes to rely upon expert B in such circumstances, the usual order should be that he can do so only on condition that he discloses the report

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

NLJ Career Profile: Maria Karaiskos KC, Church Court Chambers

NLJ Career Profile: Maria Karaiskos KC, Church Court Chambers

Maria Karaiskos KC, recently appointed as the first female head of Church Court Chambers, discusses breaking down barriers, the lure of the courtroom, and the power of storytelling

Cripps—Simon Main

Cripps—Simon Main

Firm strengthens residential property team with partner hire

Hugh James—Danielle Cahill

Hugh James—Danielle Cahill

Private wealth disputes team welcomes partner in London

NEWS
Writing in NLJ this week, Kelvin Rutledge KC of Cornerstone Barristers and Genevieve Screeche-Powell of Field Court Chambers examine the Court of Appeal’s rejection of a discrimination challenge to Tower Hamlets’ housing database
Michael Zander KC, Emeritus Professor at LSE, tracks the turbulent passage of the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill through the House of Lords in this week's issue of NLJ. Two marathon debates drew contributions from nearly 200 peers, split between support, opposition and conditional approval
Alistair Mills of Landmark Chambers reflects on the Human Rights Act 1998 a quarter-century after it came into force, in this week's issue of NLJ
In his latest Civil Way column for NLJ, Stephen Gold surveys a raft of procedural changes and quirky disputes shaping civil practice. His message is clear: civil practitioners must brace for continual tweaks, unexpected contentions and rising costs in everyday litigation
Barbara Mills KC, chair of the Bar 2025 and joint head of chambers at 4PB, sets out in this week's NLJ how the profession will respond to Baroness Harriet Harman KC’s review into bullying, harassment and sexual misconduct at the Bar
back-to-top-scroll