header-logo header-logo

Court rocks art market

06 January 2011
Issue: 7447 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-detail

Net return price agreements scrutinised in ruling

A dispute over the sale of a Leonardo Da Vinci drawing has resulted in a High Court judgment with “serious repercussions” for art dealers operating net return price agreements.

The Lichtenstein-based Accidia Foundation hired Luxembourg Art Ltd as its sole, exclusive agents to find a buyer for the Da Vinci drawing known as Madonna and Child with St Anne and a Lamb.

Luxembourg entered into a secret agreement with the art dealers, Simon C Dickinson Ltd, under which Dickinson were allowed to keep any profit over the agreed price of US$6m.

The drawing was eventually sold for US$7m and Dickinson pocketed the US$1m secret profit. 

Accidia were told the sale price was only US$6m and were given the impression that the two agent companies would simply be splitting the agreed commission of US$500,000. 

The dispute reached the High Court, in Accidia Foundation v Simon C Dickinson [2010] All ER (D) 290 (Nov), [2010] EWHC 3058 (Ch). Dickinson claimed that net return price arrangements between dealers are common practice in the art world. Mr Justice Vos said Dickinson was “unwise” for not checking the ultimate seller understood the arrangement.

Vos J ordered Dickinson to account for its profit, with compound interest, but allowed Dickinson to keep US$200,000 and £2,500 for its effort and expense in achieving the sale.

Fladgate litigation partner Paul Howcroft, who advised Accidia, said: “The case lifted the lid on the murkier parts of art dealing. It makes clear that where two dealers enter into a net return price arrangement, the selling dealer must ensure that that the owner has understood and authorised the arrangement. If not, he risks having to pay his profit or commission to the seller.”

Issue: 7447 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-details

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Birketts—trainee cohort

Birketts—trainee cohort

Firm welcomes new cohort of 29 trainee solicitors for 2025

Keoghs—four appointments

Keoghs—four appointments

Four partner hires expand legal expertise in Scotland and Northern Ireland

Brabners—Ben Lamb

Brabners—Ben Lamb

Real estate team in Yorkshire welcomes new partner

NEWS
Robert Taylor of 360 Law Services warns in this week's NLJ that adoption of artificial intelligence (AI) risks entrenching disadvantage for SME law firms, unless tools are tailored to their needs
The Court of Protection has ruled in Macpherson v Sunderland City Council that capacity must be presumed unless clearly rebutted. In this week's NLJ, Sam Karim KC and Sophie Hurst of Kings Chambers dissect the judgment and set out practical guidance for advisers faced with issues relating to retrospective capacity and/or assessments without an examination
Delays and dysfunction continue to mount in the county court, as revealed in a scathing Justice Committee report and under discussion this week by NLJ columnist Professor Dominic Regan of City Law School. Bulk claims—especially from private parking firms—are overwhelming the system, with 8,000 cases filed weekly
Charles Pigott of Mills & Reeve charts the turbulent progress of the Employment Rights Bill through the House of Lords, in this week's NLJ
From oligarchs to cosmetic clinics, strategic lawsuits against public participation (SLAPPs) target journalists, activists and ordinary citizens with intimidating legal tactics. Writing in NLJ this week, Sadie Whittam of Lancaster University explores the weaponisation of litigation to silence critics
back-to-top-scroll