header-logo header-logo

Court rocks art market

06 January 2011
Issue: 7447 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-detail

Net return price agreements scrutinised in ruling

A dispute over the sale of a Leonardo Da Vinci drawing has resulted in a High Court judgment with “serious repercussions” for art dealers operating net return price agreements.

The Lichtenstein-based Accidia Foundation hired Luxembourg Art Ltd as its sole, exclusive agents to find a buyer for the Da Vinci drawing known as Madonna and Child with St Anne and a Lamb.

Luxembourg entered into a secret agreement with the art dealers, Simon C Dickinson Ltd, under which Dickinson were allowed to keep any profit over the agreed price of US$6m.

The drawing was eventually sold for US$7m and Dickinson pocketed the US$1m secret profit. 

Accidia were told the sale price was only US$6m and were given the impression that the two agent companies would simply be splitting the agreed commission of US$500,000. 

The dispute reached the High Court, in Accidia Foundation v Simon C Dickinson [2010] All ER (D) 290 (Nov), [2010] EWHC 3058 (Ch). Dickinson claimed that net return price arrangements between dealers are common practice in the art world. Mr Justice Vos said Dickinson was “unwise” for not checking the ultimate seller understood the arrangement.

Vos J ordered Dickinson to account for its profit, with compound interest, but allowed Dickinson to keep US$200,000 and £2,500 for its effort and expense in achieving the sale.

Fladgate litigation partner Paul Howcroft, who advised Accidia, said: “The case lifted the lid on the murkier parts of art dealing. It makes clear that where two dealers enter into a net return price arrangement, the selling dealer must ensure that that the owner has understood and authorised the arrangement. If not, he risks having to pay his profit or commission to the seller.”

Issue: 7447 / Categories: Legal News
printer mail-details

MOVERS & SHAKERS

DWF—19 appointments

DWF—19 appointments

Belfast team bolstered by three senior hires and 16 further appointments

Cadwalader—Andro Atlaga

Cadwalader—Andro Atlaga

Firm strengthens leveraged finance team with London partner hire

Knights—Ella Dodgson & Rebecca Laffan

Knights—Ella Dodgson & Rebecca Laffan

Double hire marks launch of family team in Leeds

NEWS
Charles Pigott of Mills & Reeve reports on Haynes v Thomson, the first judicial application of the Supreme Court’s For Women Scotland ruling in a discrimination claim, in this week's NLJ
Charlie Mercer and Astrid Gillam of Stewarts crunch the numbers on civil fraud claims in the English courts, in this week's NLJ. New data shows civil fraud claims rising steadily since 2014, with the King’s Bench Division overtaking the Commercial Court as the forum of choice for lower-value disputes
The Supreme Court issued a landmark judgment in July that overturned the convictions of Tom Hayes and Carlo Palombo, once poster boys of the Libor and Euribor scandal. In NLJ this week, Neil Swift of Peters & Peters considers what the ruling means for financial law enforcement
Small law firms want to embrace technology but feel lost in a maze of jargon, costs and compliance fears, writes Aisling O’Connell of the Solicitors Regulation Authority in this week's NLJ
Artificial intelligence may be revolutionising the law, but its misuse could wreck cases and careers, warns Clare Arthurs of Penningtons Manches Cooper in this week's NLJ
back-to-top-scroll