header-logo header-logo

Judges as wizards—the making of legal magic

12 September 2019 / Mark Pawlowski
Issue: 7855 / Categories: Features , Procedure & practice
printer mail-detail

Mark Pawlowski questions the usefulness of legal fictions in English law

A recurring concern among both judges and legal practitioners is the fear of uncertainty in our law. As Mr Justice Harman said, in Campbell Discount v Bridge [1961] 1 QB 445, ‘the process of robust over-simplification may lead, if followed far enough, to palm-tree justice’. The days of the portable palm tree are not yet with us, but there is a growing tendency among the judiciary to latch on to a variety of legal abstractions as a means of disguising the inherently subjective nature of their decisions.

One technique for injecting objectivity into an otherwise highly subjective conclusion is to use a fictional legal character as an objective yardstick. The ‘reasonable landlord’, for example, often appears in cases where a court has to consider whether a landlord has unreasonably withheld consent to a proposed assignment of the lease or a subletting. In Ashworth Frazer v Gloucester City Council [2001] 1 WLR 2180, Lord Rodger states that the correct approach is

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Thomson Hayton Winkley—Suzie Fisher

Thomson Hayton Winkley—Suzie Fisher

Cumbria firm appoints long-serving lawyer as new managing director

Taylor Wessing—Kim Wedral

Taylor Wessing—Kim Wedral

Employment specialist joins Cambridge office as partner

Mewburn Ellis—Amy Crouch

Mewburn Ellis—Amy Crouch

Patent litigation offering boosted by partner appointment

NEWS
The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) has published a statement in a bid to clear up confusion over the right to conduct litigation following Mazur and another v Charles Russell Speechleys
Home-buyers could be given an option to sign a binding contract with vendors to protect against the practice of parties pulling out of agreements after months of negotiations, under a proposed overhaul of conveyancing laws
A future Conservative government would abolish the Sentencing Council and Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) and sack judges who defended migrants’ rights, shadow justice secretary Robert Jenrick has said
UK law firms have risen up an annual index of responsible business activity, while US firms have regressed amid President Trump’s diversity and equality crackdown
The right of the press to report on the criminal courts received a boost this week, following an update to the Criminal Procedure Rules
back-to-top-scroll