header-logo header-logo

14 August 2013 / Erika Rackley , Erika Rackley
Issue: 7573 / Categories: Features , Profession
printer mail-detail

The Neuberger Experiment

manwoman

Do female judges change the substance of decision-making, asks Erika Rackley

Is it possible to isolate the potential impact of gender, as distinct from any other identity characteristic, in any given judgment?

While few would argue against the importance of a diverse judiciary, the view that the inclusion of different perspectives on the bench would alter—let alone enrich—the substance and quality of judicial decision-making, remains controversial.

One reason for this is that there have been doubts as to how, if at all, the identity characteristics of any given judge affect how they judge, and still less whether any potential differences can be correlated and corroborated across gender, ethnicity, etc. Even if we are agreed that, on balance, it is likely that gender makes some difference to judicial decision-making, we might think that until we can demonstrate how women and men differ in their judging, arguments for increasing diversity on this basis cannot get off the ground. But how might we prove this?

The Neuberger Experiment

In May 2013, BBC Radio 4’s

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Palmers Solicitors—Hayley Grantham

Palmers Solicitors—Hayley Grantham

Palmers Solicitors strengthens property litigation team with Senior Associate appointment

Parklane Plowden Chambers—seven appointments

Parklane Plowden Chambers—seven appointments

Parklane Plowden Chambers welcomes seven new pupils

Weightmans—Paul McGough & Hewi Ma

Weightmans—Paul McGough & Hewi Ma

Weightmans’ healthcare practice continues to grow with senior hires

NEWS
Victory in litigation offers no guarantee of recovering costs, as this year’s Court of Appeal decisions underline
Payment for family care, expanding children proceedings reforms and new anti-social behaviour powers feature in a packed procedural update
Parliament must set clearer rules governing when changes in the law justify reopening criminal convictions, a former Criminal Cases Review Commission chairman argues
Confidential arbitration does not justify permanently concealing a court’s reasons, a High Court decision illustrates
Hillingdon Law Centre’s closure has revived memories of the battle that enabled it to open 50 years ago—and changed the prospects for community legal services
back-to-top-scroll