header-logo header-logo

NLJ this week: Supreme Court’s binary ruling exposes flaws in equality law

27 June 2025
Issue: 8122 / Categories: Legal News , Equality , Human rights , Diversity , Public
printer mail-detail
224105
Writing in NLJ this week, Zoë Chapman, criminal barrister at Red Lion Chambers, critiques the Supreme Court’s ruling in For Women Scotland Ltd v Scottish Ministers

The court held that ‘sex’ in the Equality Act 2010 refers to biological sex, excluding trans women with a Gender Recognition Certificate from the definition of ‘woman’.

Chapman argues this binary interpretation is reductive and outdated, ignoring medical realities like intersex conditions. While the court insists trans people retain protections under other provisions, Chapman warns the ruling may embolden blanket bans in single-sex spaces. She calls for legislative reform to reflect modern understandings of sex and gender, noting that the Equality Act is increasingly unfit for purpose.

The judgment, she concludes, may have far-reaching consequences for trans rights, public services, and legal clarity—raising urgent questions about how equality is defined and defended in law.

Issue: 8122 / Categories: Legal News , Equality , Human rights , Diversity , Public
printer mail-details
RELATED ARTICLES

MOVERS & SHAKERS

NLJ Career Profile: Kate Gaskell, Flex Legal

NLJ Career Profile: Kate Gaskell, Flex Legal

Kate Gaskell, CEO of Flex Legal, reflects on chasing her childhood dreams underscores the importance of welcoming those from all backgrounds into the profession

Dorsey & Whitney—Jonathan Christy

Dorsey & Whitney—Jonathan Christy

Dispute resolution team welcomes associate in London

Winckworth Sherwood—Kevin McManamon

Winckworth Sherwood—Kevin McManamon

Special education needs and mental capacity expert joins as partner

NEWS
Overcrowded prisons, mental health hospitals and immigration centres are failing to meet international and domestic human rights standards, the National Preventive Mechanism (NPM) has warned
Two speedier and more streamlined qualification routes have been launched for probate and conveyancing professionals
Workplace stress was a contributing factor in almost one in eight cases before the employment tribunal last year, indicating its endemic grip on the UK workplace
In NLJ this week, Ian Smith, emeritus professor at UEA, explores major developments in employment law from the Supreme Court and appellate courts
Writing in NLJ this week, Kamran Rehman and Harriet Campbell of Penningtons Manches Cooper examine Operafund Eco-Invest SICAV plc v Spain, where the Commercial Court held that ICSID and Energy Charter Treaty awards cannot be assigned
back-to-top-scroll