header-logo header-logo

16 December 2022 / David Hewitt
Issue: 8007 / Categories: Features , Media , Defamation
printer mail-detail

Silent night (at the cinema)

104745
David Hewitt explores one of the most intriguing characters to emerge during the trial of the controversial Five Nights film

Of all the exotic characters to emerge during the Five Nights trial, none was more exotic than Sir Montague Shearman.

Mr Justice Shearman

The trial concerned a silent film that was at that moment outraging half the country (see ‘Shocks on screen: the case of Five Nights’, NLJ, 28 October 2022, p22), and Mr Justice Shearman, to give him his full title, was the presiding judge.

Born two decades into Queen Victoria’s reign, the son of a solicitor from Wimbledon, he went on to earn a ‘double-first’ degree from Oxford University. And though the men associated with the film included one who used a whip on his rivals, and another who would be sued by Charlie Chaplin, none of them would ever hold a candle to him.

‘Tont’ Shearman boxed and rowed, ran the 100 yards in barely ten seconds, and helped himself to a rugby

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Thackray Williams—Lucy Zhu

Thackray Williams—Lucy Zhu

Dual-qualified partner joins as head of commercial property department

Morgan Lewis—David A. McManus

Morgan Lewis—David A. McManus

Firm announces appointment of next chair

Burges Salmon—Rebecca Wilsker

Burges Salmon—Rebecca Wilsker

Director joins corporate team from the US

NEWS
What safeguards apply when trust corporations are appointed as deputy by the Court of Protection? 
Disputing parties are expected to take part in alternative dispute resolution (ADR), where this is suitable for their case. At what point, however, does refusing to participate cross the threshold of ‘unreasonable’ and attract adverse costs consequences?
When it comes to free legal advice, demand massively outweighs supply. 'Millions of people are excluded from access to justice as they don’t have anywhere to turn for free advice—or don’t know that they can ask for help,' Bhavini Bhatt, development director at the Access to Justice Foundation, writes in this week's NLJ
When an ex-couple is deciding who gets what in the divorce or civil partnership dissolution, when is it appropriate for a third party to intervene? David Burrows, NLJ columnist and solicitor advocate, considers this thorny issue in this week’s NLJ
NLJ's latest Charities Appeals Supplement has been published in this week’s issue
back-to-top-scroll