header-logo header-logo

29 April 2011 / Roger Smith
Issue: 7463 / Categories: Opinion , Legal aid focus , Human rights
printer mail-detail

Trials & tribulations

Roger Smith reflects on detainees, masterly performances & Daily Mail fulmination

America’s star 9/11 detainee will, after all, be tried by a military commission. The Obama administration’s original plan to use civilian courts has been defeated. Attorney General Eric Hodder’s final capitulation was forced by Congress restrictions on the use of military funds to bring Khalid Sheikh Mohammed (KSM) from Guantanamo to the US.

The trial of KSM, wherever held, poses difficulties. On the one hand, he has confessed to involvement in just about every major terrorist event involving Al Qaeda since the mid-1990s. This included the boast that “I decapitated with my blessed right hand the head of the American Jew, Daniel Pearl” and that he was responsible for 31 specific operations led by the “9/11 operation from A to Z”. The problem is, the US owns up to treatment everyone else would call torture since his arrest in 2003: its agents waterboarded him no less than 183 times.

KSM indicated three years ago that he would plead guilty. He may, indeed,

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

WSP Solicitors—David Ashcroft & Jessica O’Shea

WSP Solicitors—David Ashcroft & Jessica O’Shea

Commercial property and child law teams expand with senior hires

Duxton Hill Chambers—Lucas Bastin KC & Joshua Hiew

Duxton Hill Chambers—Lucas Bastin KC & Joshua Hiew

Set expands London and Singapore offering with senior international disputes hires

Gilson Gray—Gregor Duthie & Stephen Forsyth

Gilson Gray—Gregor Duthie & Stephen Forsyth

Firm strengthens real estate and litigation teams with partner promotions

NEWS
Uber has built a formidable strategy for insulating itself from liability for drivers’ conduct, but the legal terrain differs sharply between the US and England and Wales
The Civil Justice Council’s review of Part III of the Solicitors Act 1974 could mark the end of what one commentator calls an ‘outdated’ and overly technical regime governing solicitor-client fee disputes
The House of Lords (Hereditary Peers) Act 2026 marks a constitutional watershed by severing the centuries-old link between hereditary titles and automatic membership of the upper chamber
Artificial intelligence, proportionality and public decision-making are under increasing judicial scrutiny, according to the latest public law round-up from Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer
Families relying on informal agreements over property ownership could face costly consequences if disputes arise, the High Court has warned
back-to-top-scroll