header-logo header-logo

13 November 2008
Issue: 7345 / Categories: Opinion , Employment
printer mail-detail

The unbelievable truth

Absurd circumstances are a daily occurrence at the coalface of employment law, says Ian Smith

“A worker (admittedly not an employee) who had been investigated for misconduct following a police investigation claimed that he had been victimised because he had blown the whistle on a third party, but before these matters could come to a head he was made redundant under a procedure operating partly on LIFO. Discuss.”

One of the beauties of lecturing employment law is that you do not have to make up daft examples for illustrations or exam questions; they tend to arise naturally. In the fine tradition of academic exaggeration, the above facts did not occur this month in one case, but in four. However, we must never let the facts get in the way of a good story.

Redrow Homes: the continuing tale
Readers will recall that the case of Redrow Homes (Yorkshire) Ltd v Wright [2004] IRLR 720, [2004] 3 All ER 98 was one of those that emphasised that the “worker” definition in the Working Time Regulations 1998 (SI 1998/1833)

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

NLJ Career Profile: Nick Vernon, Walkers Bermuda

NLJ Career Profile: Nick Vernon, Walkers Bermuda

Nick Vernon of Walkers on swapping Birmingham for Bermuda and building an employment practice by the sea

Bird & Bird—Christian Bartsch

Bird & Bird—Christian Bartsch

Global firm re-elects CEO for second term

Fletchers Group—Miriam Hall

Fletchers Group—Miriam Hall

Business appoints managing director of operational excellence

NEWS

From blockbuster judgments to procedural shake-ups, the courts are busy reshaping litigation practice. Writing in NLJ this week, Professor Dominic Regan of City Law School hails the Court of Appeal's 'exquisite judgment’ in Mazur restoring the role of supervised non-qualified staff, and highlights a ‘mammoth’ damages ruling likened to War and Peace, alongside guidance on medical reporting fees, where a pragmatic 25% uplift was imposed

Momentum is building behind proposals to restrict children’s access to social media—but the legal and practical challenges are formidable. In NLJ this week, Nick Smallwood of Mills & Reeve examines global moves, including Australia’s under-16 ban and the UK's consultation
Reforms designed to rebalance landlord-tenant relations may instead penalise leaseholders themselves. In this week's NLJ, Mike Somekh of The Freehold Collective warns that the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024 risks creating an ‘underclass’ of resident-controlled freehold companies
Timing is everything—and the Court of Appeal has delivered clarity on when proceedings are ‘brought’. In his latest 'Civil way' column for NLJ, Stephen Gold explains that a claim is issued for limitation purposes when the claim form is delivered to the court, even if fees are underpaid
The traditional ‘single, intensive day’ of financial dispute resolution (FDR) may be due for a rethink. Writing in NLJ this week, Rachel Frost-Smith and Lauren Guiler of Birketts propose a ‘split FDR’ model, separating judicial evaluation from negotiation
back-to-top-scroll