header-logo header-logo

17 January 2014 / Russell Caller
Issue: 7590 / Categories: Features , Wills & Probate
printer mail-detail

For the best?

web_caller

Is mediation the key to solving MCA 2005 “best interests” disputes, asks Russell Caller

Who hasn’t taken on a seemingly straight-forward deputyship, only to find along the way that formerly disinterested family members are suddenly experts on what’s in their incapacitated relative’s “best interests”?

Let’s face it—human nature dictates that inter-family disputes or disagreements between family members and the court appointed decision-maker—are just part of the daily grind of a professional deputy. If a local authority is involved, then add in a liberal sprinkling of resource agendas and service provision goals. As the Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA 2005) Code of Practice obliges us to always act in our client’s best interests, we are consequently duty bound to tease out and weigh up this jumble of competing evidence and heavily-charged views. Sometimes the best we can hope for is a complicated and arduous journey to reach that “best interests” decision—at worst we find ourselves embroiled in entrenched stalemate.

The right approach?

Now it’s true that the Code of Practice contains numerous suggestions on how

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Haynes Boone—Louise Woods

Haynes Boone—Louise Woods

Haynes Boone expands global capabilities with addition of Louise Woods as chair of international disputes

DWF—John Gilfedder

DWF—John Gilfedder

DWF strengthens Global Risks practice with strategic hire of aviation partner in London

Shakespeare Martineau—10 newly qualified solicitors

Shakespeare Martineau—10 newly qualified solicitors

Shakespeare Martineau appoints newly qualified solicitors

NEWS
The Thirlwall Inquiry has exposed a ‘complete failure’ to protect babies at the Countess of Chester Hospital, but its recommendations must now be put into practice
More than 500 former rugby players can pursue brain injury claims despite serious failures to disclose documents ordered by the High Court
A divorced woman has secured funding to participate in her former husband’s inquest after the Legal Aid Agency reconsidered repeated refusals
Developers in areas with poorly performing councils can apply directly to the Planning Inspectorate for permission under section 62A of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
When does a solicitor’s retainer become a contentious business agreement? The Court of Appeal’s decision in Broadfield Law UK LLP v Barnes shows that listing hourly rates alone will not do, leaving firms and clients uncertain about their rights over bills
back-to-top-scroll