header-logo header-logo

25 February 2011 / Stephen Levinson
Issue: 7454 / Categories: Features , Employment
printer mail-detail

The reform carousel

new_image_30_4

Stephen Levinson assesses the government’s tribunal bandwagon

Those familiar with some history may be forgiven for thinking that the government’s recent consultation paper, Resolving Workplace Disputes, was written by amnesiacs. For an institution less than 50 years old employment tribunals have been much reviewed.

There was Justice in 1987; the green paper, Options for Reform in 1994; Fairness at Work in 1998; the Leggatt Report in 2001 and, in 2002, the very thorough report of the Employment Tribunal System Taskforce (ETST). There was a white paper in 2004, and in 2007 the Ministry of Justice chipped in with Transforming Tribunals. Then again in 2010 the secretive Tribunal Steering Board came up with a Report on Consistency. What is notable about the current offering is that although many of the 13 ideas proposed have appeared before in one or more of those reports no acknowledgement of this appears anywhere.

Alarmingly the only mention to previous work on tribunals is to the Gibbons Review of 2007—a piece of matchless political expediency—which told the world what

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Clarke Willmott—Kevin Joynes & Neil Gosling

Clarke Willmott—Kevin Joynes & Neil Gosling

Clarke Willmott bolsters housebuilder expertise in Birmingham

Carpmaels & Ransford—Kevin Cordina

Carpmaels & Ransford—Kevin Cordina

Firm adds former Simmons Simmons patent head to engineering and tech team

ACTAPS—Sally Goodger

ACTAPS—Sally Goodger

Freeths strengthens its voice in national disputes with ACTAPS committee appointment

NEWS
Pastries may be in the firing line while kebabs escape scrutiny, but the reality is far more nuanced
The Supreme Court’s decision in Dillon highlights a central tension in modern public law: rights may be recognised without being fully realised
A landmark ruling has delivered the first judicial application of the UK’s anti-SLAPP regime and provided fresh guidance on abusive litigation
Non-court dispute resolution is no longer an alternative in family law—it is rapidly becoming the norm
Some employment law controversies never disappear—they merely lie dormant
back-to-top-scroll