header-logo header-logo

Silence is golden

30 June 2023 / Mary Young
Issue: 8031 / Categories: Features , Disclosure , Fraud , In Court
printer mail-detail
128483
Holding your tongue? Mary Young considers when a party’s right to silence applies in civil proceedings
  • How and when the privilege against self-incrimination (the right to silence) applies in civil proceedings.

In English criminal law, a suspect has a long-recognised right to remain silent. The police caution specifically reminds a suspect that they do not have to say anything, but that it might harm their defence if they do not mention something which they later rely on in court.

In civil claims with criminal or quasi-criminal implications, the right to remain silent can also apply: a defendant has the right not to give evidence, and is also entitled to assert the privilege against self-incrimination to avoid circumstances in which they are compelled to contribute to their own prosecution.

The principle of the privilege against self-incrimination originated from the common law, later codified in s 14 of the Civil Evidence Act 1968. This sets out that in proceedings other than criminal proceedings, a person has the right to refuse to answer

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

DWF—Ed Williams

DWF—Ed Williams

Public sector disputes capability bolstered by partner hire in Leeds

Blake Morgan—Scott Hilton, Joan Yu & Melia Hirst

Blake Morgan—Scott Hilton, Joan Yu & Melia Hirst

Firm strengthens corporate, real estate and insolvency teams with partner trio

Seddons GSC—David Seal & Emma Clifford

Seddons GSC—David Seal & Emma Clifford

Consultant and solicitor join commercial real estate team

NEWS
Legal advice to people detained in police stations could be delivered by video link, Sir Brian Leveson has said, in part two of his Independent Review of the Criminal Courts
The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) has urged the government to move towards a less adversarial system of clinical negligence, after the total cost to the NHS quadrupled within 20 years to an eye-watering £60bn
Peers have warned impending legislation could put executors at financial risk when their loved ones die
Legal IT supplier InfoTrack has launched a conveyancing tool that speeds up the pre-contract enquiries stage by allowing both sides to collaborate in one shared workspace
Barristers met with 19 of their local MPs at ten Crown Courts in all six circuits last week, as part of a Bar Council and Criminal Bar Association initiative to defend juries and explain the factors behind the backlog of nearly 80,000 cases
back-to-top-scroll