header-logo header-logo

13 December 2013
Issue: 7588 / Categories: Case law , Law digest , In Court
printer mail-detail

Anti-suit injunction

Insurance Company of the State of Pennsylvania v Equitas Insurance Ltd [2013] EWHC 3713 (Comm), [2013] All ER (D) 18 (Dec)

The claimant brought an action in England claiming to be indemnified by the defendant, pursuant to three contracts of reinsurance. After several months of negotiations in respect of the English claims, it launched a claim in New York, allegedly without informing the defendant. The defendant, having become aware of the New York claim, applied for an anti-suit injunction. The claimant applied for a stay of the English proceedings pending the US court’s determination of Equitas Insurance Ltd’s motions for a stay. The court ruled that it was settled law that the English court should favour its own conflict of law rules and, under those rules, it was overwhelmingly likely that English law governed the formation and meaning and effect of the reinsurance contracts. It was settled law that where a claimant had brought a claim against the same defendants for essentially the same relief arising out of the same facts in two jurisdictions, then, absent special

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Anthony Collins—William Hallett & Lorna Scully

Anthony Collins—William Hallett & Lorna Scully

Anthony Collins hires two talented legal directors

Switalskis—five appointments

Switalskis—five appointments

Firm expands national abuse compensation team

Mathys & Squire—nine promotions

Mathys & Squire—nine promotions

IP firm announces new partners and senior promotions across UK offices

NEWS
Executors may be overlooking billions of pounds in estate assets hidden in forgotten investments and misplaced share certificates
Britain’s booming non-surgical cosmetics market is operating in what some critics describe as a regulatory ‘Wild West’
Family contact disputes are becoming an increasingly prominent feature of Court of Protection litigation
Material obtained through US discovery applications may have a much longer legal life than many litigants realise
English courts are developing a distinctly practical approach to sanctions disputes arising from Russia’s invasion of Ukraine
back-to-top-scroll